TFIPOST हिन्दी
TFIPOST Global
Tfipost.com
Tfipost.com
No Result
View All Result
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
    Shivaji’s Southern Triumph

    Chhatrapati Shivaji’s Southern Legacy: The Maratha Flame in Tamil Nadu

    LeT’s Muridke Exit: Bahawalpur the New Hub

    Pakistan’s Terror Map Shifts as Lashkar-e-Taiba Flees 400 km South from Muridke to Bahawalpur After Op Sindoor

    Even Terrorists Are Treated Better": Imran Khan Alleges Targeted Abuse

    Treated Worse Than Terrorist: Imran Khan Blames Army Chief Asim Munir for Jail Torture

    Raj Thackeray Warns BJP MP: ‘We’ll Drown You in Mumbai’s Sea’ Over Marathi Row

    Dubo Dubo Ke Maarenge : Raj Thackeray Threatens to Drown BJP MP Nishikant Dubey

    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • All
    • Business
    • Economy1
    • Finance
    Air India Crash: US Safety Board Urges Caution Amid Ongoing Investigation

    Air India Crash: US Safety Board Urges Caution Amid Ongoing Investigation

    AI Appreciation Day Celebrated Globally, Spotlight on Innovation and Ethical Progress

    AI Appreciation Day Celebrated Globally, Spotlight on Innovation and Ethical Progress

    India Achieves 50% Non-Fossil Fuel Power Capacity

    India Achieves 50 pc Non-Fossil Fuel Power Capacity, Five Years Ahead of Schedule

    Advantages of Using an EMI Calculator Before Applying for a Personal Loan

    Advantages of Using an EMI Calculator Before Applying for a Personal Loan

    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • All
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
    Strategic Shift: Bitra Island for Defence Forces

    India Secures Strategic Edge: Centre Moves to Acquire Bitra Island in Lakshadweep for Defence Forces

    India Successfully Tests Prithvi-II and Agni-I Ballistic Missiles

    India Successfully Tests Nuclear Capable Agni-I & Prithvi-II Ballistic Missiles in Odisha, Strengthens Strategic Deterrence

    Successful Test of ‘Akash Prime Air Defence System’ in Ladakh

    Successful Test of ‘Akash Prime Air Defence System’ at 15,000 Feet in Ladakh

    CDS Chauhan: India Needs Tomorrow’s Tech to Win Today’s Wars

    India Needs Tomorrow’s Tech to Win Today’s Wars, Says CDS Anil Chauhan; Urges Indigenous Tech Push

    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • All
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
    TRF Declared Global Terror Outfit After India’s Swift Diplomatic Strike

    India’s 72-Hour Blitz After Pahalgam Gets TRF Blacklisted by Washington

    TRF Ban a Win for India: Renewed Momentum to Greylist Pakistan at FATF

    TRF Sanctioned: Will Pakistan’s Terror Nexus Drag It Back to FATF Grey List?

    US Declares Pakistan’s Lashkar Proxy TRF a Terror Outfit,

    Pahalgam Massacre: US Declares Pakistan’s Lashkar Proxy TRF a Terror Outfit, Cites Trump’s Justice Call

    Baloch Insurgents Kill 29 Soldiers: Pakistan Army Losing Control in Balochistan

    Is Balochistan Slipping Away from Pak? 29 Soldiers Killed as BLA, BLF Launch Simultaneous Attacks

    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • All
    • Culture
    • Education
    • History
    • Indology
    NCERT Textbook Reveals Mughal Religious Intolerance

    Ruthless Babur, Violent Akbar, Destructive Aurangzeb: NCERT Textbook Reveals Mughal Religious Intolerance

    India Built Gardens Long Before Babur Dreamt of Charbagh

    Before the Mughals: India’s Civilisation Built Gardens Long Before Babur Dreamt of Charbaghs

    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    Echoes of the Cholas in Today’s Bharat

    Conqueror of the Seas: Rajendra Chola and the Rise of Naval Bharat

    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • All
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Entertainment
    • Food
    • Games
    • Health
    • Lifestyle
    • Satire
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    One in Four Indian Married Couples Are Now Overweight

    ICMR Study: One in Four Indian Married Couples Are Now Overweight or Obese—Shared Lifestyle to Blame

    Review Batery Casino India

    Review Batery Casino India

    What Learners Say about Simplilearn AI Course Reviews?

    What Learners Say about Simplilearn AI Course Reviews?

    Karnataka Govt Blames RCB for Chinnaswamy Stampede

    Congress- led Karnataka Govt Blames RCB for Chinnaswamy Stampede, Cites Kohli’s Video in HC

    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
Tfipost.com
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
    Shivaji’s Southern Triumph

    Chhatrapati Shivaji’s Southern Legacy: The Maratha Flame in Tamil Nadu

    LeT’s Muridke Exit: Bahawalpur the New Hub

    Pakistan’s Terror Map Shifts as Lashkar-e-Taiba Flees 400 km South from Muridke to Bahawalpur After Op Sindoor

    Even Terrorists Are Treated Better": Imran Khan Alleges Targeted Abuse

    Treated Worse Than Terrorist: Imran Khan Blames Army Chief Asim Munir for Jail Torture

    Raj Thackeray Warns BJP MP: ‘We’ll Drown You in Mumbai’s Sea’ Over Marathi Row

    Dubo Dubo Ke Maarenge : Raj Thackeray Threatens to Drown BJP MP Nishikant Dubey

    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • All
    • Business
    • Economy1
    • Finance
    Air India Crash: US Safety Board Urges Caution Amid Ongoing Investigation

    Air India Crash: US Safety Board Urges Caution Amid Ongoing Investigation

    AI Appreciation Day Celebrated Globally, Spotlight on Innovation and Ethical Progress

    AI Appreciation Day Celebrated Globally, Spotlight on Innovation and Ethical Progress

    India Achieves 50% Non-Fossil Fuel Power Capacity

    India Achieves 50 pc Non-Fossil Fuel Power Capacity, Five Years Ahead of Schedule

    Advantages of Using an EMI Calculator Before Applying for a Personal Loan

    Advantages of Using an EMI Calculator Before Applying for a Personal Loan

    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • All
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
    Strategic Shift: Bitra Island for Defence Forces

    India Secures Strategic Edge: Centre Moves to Acquire Bitra Island in Lakshadweep for Defence Forces

    India Successfully Tests Prithvi-II and Agni-I Ballistic Missiles

    India Successfully Tests Nuclear Capable Agni-I & Prithvi-II Ballistic Missiles in Odisha, Strengthens Strategic Deterrence

    Successful Test of ‘Akash Prime Air Defence System’ in Ladakh

    Successful Test of ‘Akash Prime Air Defence System’ at 15,000 Feet in Ladakh

    CDS Chauhan: India Needs Tomorrow’s Tech to Win Today’s Wars

    India Needs Tomorrow’s Tech to Win Today’s Wars, Says CDS Anil Chauhan; Urges Indigenous Tech Push

    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • All
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
    TRF Declared Global Terror Outfit After India’s Swift Diplomatic Strike

    India’s 72-Hour Blitz After Pahalgam Gets TRF Blacklisted by Washington

    TRF Ban a Win for India: Renewed Momentum to Greylist Pakistan at FATF

    TRF Sanctioned: Will Pakistan’s Terror Nexus Drag It Back to FATF Grey List?

    US Declares Pakistan’s Lashkar Proxy TRF a Terror Outfit,

    Pahalgam Massacre: US Declares Pakistan’s Lashkar Proxy TRF a Terror Outfit, Cites Trump’s Justice Call

    Baloch Insurgents Kill 29 Soldiers: Pakistan Army Losing Control in Balochistan

    Is Balochistan Slipping Away from Pak? 29 Soldiers Killed as BLA, BLF Launch Simultaneous Attacks

    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • All
    • Culture
    • Education
    • History
    • Indology
    NCERT Textbook Reveals Mughal Religious Intolerance

    Ruthless Babur, Violent Akbar, Destructive Aurangzeb: NCERT Textbook Reveals Mughal Religious Intolerance

    India Built Gardens Long Before Babur Dreamt of Charbagh

    Before the Mughals: India’s Civilisation Built Gardens Long Before Babur Dreamt of Charbaghs

    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    Echoes of the Cholas in Today’s Bharat

    Conqueror of the Seas: Rajendra Chola and the Rise of Naval Bharat

    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • All
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Entertainment
    • Food
    • Games
    • Health
    • Lifestyle
    • Satire
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    One in Four Indian Married Couples Are Now Overweight

    ICMR Study: One in Four Indian Married Couples Are Now Overweight or Obese—Shared Lifestyle to Blame

    Review Batery Casino India

    Review Batery Casino India

    What Learners Say about Simplilearn AI Course Reviews?

    What Learners Say about Simplilearn AI Course Reviews?

    Karnataka Govt Blames RCB for Chinnaswamy Stampede

    Congress- led Karnataka Govt Blames RCB for Chinnaswamy Stampede, Cites Kohli’s Video in HC

    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
No Result
View All Result
Tfipost.com
Tfipost.com
No Result
View All Result
  • Premium
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Defense
  • Geopolitics
  • Knowledge
  • Law
  • Lounge

Factchecker BoomLive tagged our article on Amartya Sen as Fake News. Here’s our response

Ashish Dwivedi by Ashish Dwivedi
11 May 2019
in Analysis
Factchecker BoomLive tagged our article on Amartya Sen as Fake News. Here’s our response
Share on FacebookShare on X

In an interview in 2016, Govind Ethiraj, the founder of IndiaSpend, BoomLive, and Factchecker, claimed, “Most of the fake news is originating from people aligned with the BJP (Bharatiya Janata Party).” To expect nuanced understanding of political discourse, necessary for countering the bane of today’s politics, fake news, from this blatantly prejudiced viewpoint is a futile exercise. Yet, one is bound to at least expect a semblance of integrity and impartiality from a fact-checker certified by the International Fact Checking Network- Poynter Institute. It seems, however, these expectations are grossly misplaced.

On April 28, 2019, Editor- Internal Security, Times of India, Bharti Jain in a series of tweets claimed a number of irregularities in the Nalanda University project. Coming from a senior editor of a reputed national daily, the claims carried certain weight and for websites like us who source their news from such outlets, the claims were nothing short of a scoop. Despite the seeming irresistibility of the claims, and the seniority and position of authority they were coming from, we decided to dig deeper. Bharti Jain had made many claims in her tweets. After thorough research, we decided to do an article, not on the claims made by Bharti Jain but the entire Nalanda University controversy. Admittedly, we found that many of the claims made by Bharti Jain could not be verified from other sources. So we duly decided to discard the claims which were contradictory to other publicly available sources. Instead, we solely chose to focus on the Comptroller and Auditor General Report ending in March 2016 which had plenty of damning statements regarding the University’s controversial appointments and practices under the aegis of Amartya Sen. We included one quote, with due attribution, from Bharti Jain.

RelatedPosts

‘Show Me One Photo of Indian Damage’: NSA Doval Destroys Foreign Media’s Propaganda on Op Sindoor

Karnataka’s Proposed Fake News Bill Raises Concerns Over Free Speech

I was not detained: IIT Baba rubbishes claims of his arrest while celebrating his birthday

Load More

Despite the caution we had exercised and the due diligence accorded to the story, imagine our shock and horror when within few days, we received a notification stating that the article we had done on the Nalanda controversy was marked as ‘fake news’ by an ‘independent fact-checker’, BoomLive.

BoomLive has provided a complete list of claims and counterclaims in its fact-check. However, the only problem with the fact-check is that before including rightlog’s name, it seems they did not even bother to read the entire article.

BoomLive’s first ‘fact-check’ is about the misinformation on Amartya Sen’s salary and his administrative power (or lack thereof, according to the fact-check).

The problem with the fact-check is, we never included or claimed Dr. Sen’s salary in our article or any other perks he may or may not have received. We did, however, talk about his influence on crucial appointments.

And this is where BoomLive, in its zeal to anyhow term our article fake news, gets facts wrong. The BoomLive article categorically states that “In Indian universities, the position of Chancellor is ceremonial, and does not have any administrative functions” indicating that Dr. Sen was administrative in-charge only in theory not in practice. The article further hammers the point of Sen being a figurehead, “Therefore, Sen was never conferred the power to ‘run’ the institution.”

However, this is in stark contrast to the CAG report observations. The CAG report categorically states that in direct violation of the norms, “Chairman of the NMG [Amartya Sen], recommended (6 February 2009) three names (Dr. Gopa Sabharwal, Dr. Ramachandra Guha and Dr. Pratap Bhanu Mehta) on behalf of NMG to the MEA for appointment as first Rector of the University. Based on the above recommendations, MEA intimated (March 2009) Dr. Gopa Sabharwal, that she has been selected for the post of inaugural Rector of the Nalanda University. Hence, consideration of the names recommended by NMG was in violation of their terms of reference.” So, it seems despite not being ‘theoretically’ in power, Dr. Sen was influencing appointments at Nalanda University in practice. This aspect has been further corroborated in an article by Priyadarshi Dutta in Daily Pioneer (February 2015). Dutta writes, The two Comptroller and Auditor General audits undertaken as per Clause 32 (1) of the Nalanda University Act, 2010, nailed irregularities in the appointment of a Vice Chancellor, who was offered an exorbitant salary, with Mr Sen’s final approval.”

The CAG report further sheds light on the irregularities in appointments (which we had covered in our original article).  It is necessary here to bust BoomLive’s claims of Dr. Sen being the ‘figurative head’ of Nalanda University. The CAG report notes, “Audit examination of records of the MEA revealed that although the terms of reference of NMG did not include recommendations for any appointment, NMG in its 6th meeting recommended (August 2010) single name of Dr. Gopa Sabharwal as Vice-Chancellor-designate for Nalanda University. The NMG also proposed salary of Rs 3.50 lakh per month plus other allowances. MEA, based on this recommendation, informed (9 September 2010) Dr. Gopa Sabharwal that the competent authorities have accorded approval for appointment as Vice Chancellor-designate with salary of Rs 2.00 lakh per month plus other allowances. She joined as Vice Chancellor designate of Nalanda University on 8 October 2010. However, the Visitor confirmed (March 2012) her appointment as Vice Chancellor with retrospective effect from 8 October 2010. Subsequently MEA (September 2012) informed Dr. Gopa Sabharwal that her confirmation date has been changed to 25 November 2010 i.e. from the date on which Nalanda University Act came into force.”

It is very clear that NMG, headed by Dr. Sen, not only influenced appointments in direct violation of the University Statutes but also retrospectively changed the date of V-C’s appointment which enabled her to accrue undue salary and benefits. 

The NMG itself, headed by Dr. Sen, was appointed for only 9 months until the submission of a detailed project report but that project report was repeatedly delayed and the NMG’s tenure repeatedly extended. Eventually, NMG was transformed into Nalanda University governing body which was to be in power for one year but kept getting extensions. Curiously enough, the rule for Chancellor’s appointment was outlined in University Statute, 2012 notified on March 2012. However, Dr. Sen was appointed the Chancellor by the governing body he was leading during the third governing body meeting held in Beijing in October 2011.

In the face of evidence and observations by the CAG, it would be indeed very naïve to imagine that Dr. Sen was ‘figurative head’ of Nalanda University with no real ‘administrative power’ as the BoomLive article claims. It is indeed downright misleading to assert that.

In fact, the very governing body that Dr. Sen headed had come under scrutiny by the Finance Ministry…of UPA government in 2014. The finance ministry had raised concerns about “the huge expenditure being incurred on maintaining the governing body of the university, known earlier as the Nalanda Mentor Group, as well as the tax-free salaries to the tune of $80,000 dollars per year to some of the top functionaries of the university.”

Instead of providing clarity on the issue, Dr. Sen had threatened to resign if the government refuses to ‘quash the objections of financial mismanagement’. Ultimately, the finance ministry under UPA did back down and Dr. Sen’s reign continued over the Nalanda University.

The incident, however, raises the question if Dr. Sen was indeed a ‘figurative head’ and was not ‘running’ the institution then why did he refuse any sort of scrutiny over governing body’s financial (mis)management? Is it not, then, dishonesty on the part of BoomLive to claim that Dr. Sen was not actually ‘running’ the institution?

Irregularities in appointments aside, the CAG report had also included several other damning indictments of NMG (later Governing Body) headed by Dr. Sen, which we covered in our article with due attribution to CAG document. With regard to Dr. Sen, we did not make any claims that were not in the CAG report itself. 

The second point marked by BoomLive fact-check is that ‘total expenditure incurred was Rs. 2729 crore’.  However, we did not include any sort of expenditure of specific amount in our article instead focusing on procedural and administrative irregularities mentioned in the CAG report.

 

The third point in the BoomLive fact-check ‘busts’ the claims of Dr Gopa Sabharwal, Dr Anjana Sharma, Nayanjot Lahiri and Upinder Singh from Delhi University being made faculties.

As has been established, Dr. Gopa Sabharwal was appointed the Vice-Chancellor which we have covered in our article. Apart from these, except Upinder Singh, we have not mentioned any names provided here. As far as Upinder Singh’s appointment is concerned, it was reported by Bihar Times and later covered by One India which we have cited in our article. Upinder Singh’s appointment as faculty was also covered by Scroll.in (February 2015) citing Bihar Times article. As is evident, we had three different sources corroborating that fact and we chose to include it in our report. Citing a fact which has been reported by three different reputed outlets can hardly be termed fake news and even if it could be, the onus of the report’s veracity is on the original source.

The fourth contentious point BoomLive raises in its fact-check is the appointment of Daman Singh and Amrit Singh, Dr. Manmohan Singh’s daughters, as honorary faculty at Nalanda University. This is the only point we chose to include in our article. As we have mentioned earlier, senior editor of a reputed national daily was making the claim and unlike the previous points, we did not find any contradictory evidence to this claim and as such relying on the Bharti Jain’s tweet, we chose to include this point. Notably, Bharti Jain has neither deleted this particular tweet nor she has offered any retractions. We had properly attributed this particular statement to Bharti Jain and we stand by with our original decision.

Coming to the last point of BoomLive article, it contradicts the claims that ‘after 2014, when Modi arrived, all these fraud were stopped and Amartya Sen was thrown out of Nalanda University (sic)’.

We had made no such claims in our article.

It is very clear by now that the inclusion of rightlog’s name in this sham of a fact-check by BoomLive was driven by malicious agenda and it is indeed very likely that BoomLive did not even bother to go through the article before terming it as ‘fake news.’ The fact-check by BoomLive is riddled with inaccuracies (as has been earlier pointed out) and in fact, can be characterized as fake news given their selective omission and inclusion of facts and context. The CAG report which formed the basis of our article and which is perhaps the most authoritative and exhaustive account of Dr. Sen’s (mis)management of Nalanda University, is not even mentioned in its fact-check.

The point of the entire fact-check is not to find the truth but to somehow tag rightlog as a fake news peddler. It is a shoddily executed hatchet job by well-placed mercenaries, a clear abuse of whatever little power they have.

Tags: BoomliveFake NewsIndiaSpend
Share131TweetSend
Previous Post

Priyanka’s arrest is not a lone case. Here’s a look at the history of Mamata’s censorship over freedom of speech

Next Post

HCL overtakes Wipro to become the third largest IT company in India

Related Posts

LeT’s Muridke Exit: Bahawalpur the New Hub
Analysis

Pakistan’s Terror Map Shifts as Lashkar-e-Taiba Flees 400 km South from Muridke to Bahawalpur After Op Sindoor

19 July 2025

After decades of hiding behind the Pakistani Army’s protection, Lashkar-e-Taiba is on the run. Rattled by the sheer scale...

Lalu Yadav Family Feud May Derail RJD as Discontent Grows Within
Analysis

Bihar Polls: Lalu Yadav’s Family Feud May Derail RJD’s Plans as Discontent Grows Within

15 July 2025

The Rashtriya Janata Dal, once a dominant force in Bihar politics, appears to be grappling with growing internal discord,...

India Must Stay Vigilant as Turkey-Pakistan Axis Grows
Analysis

Pakistan and Turkey Deepen Anti-India Axis Through Defence, Radicalization Nexus

14 July 2025

In a move that raises fresh concerns for India’s national security, Pakistan and Turkey (Türkiye) are forging deeper military,...

Load More

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms of use and Privacy Policy.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Currently Playing

The Forgotten Maratha Legacy in Tamil Nadu

The Forgotten Maratha Legacy in Tamil Nadu

00:07:37

India’s ULRA Bomber: 12,000-km Beast That Can Strike Anywhere Without Refueling

00:07:39

The Shocking Truth About Mass Conversions in Tamil Nadu

00:07:26

The Butcher of Pahalgam: Sulaiman — Trained by ISI, Pakistan’s Commando-Turned-Terrorist

00:04:13

Congress’s Rohith Vemula Bill: Caste Polarization Masquerading as Reform

00:07:33
Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube
tfipostTfipost.com
Right Wing | News Analysis | Indian Opinion
  • About us
  • Careers
  • Brand Partnerships
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
MASHABLE IS A GLOBAL, MULTI-PLATFORM MEDIA AND ENTERTAINMENT COMPANY. FOR MORE QUERIES AND NEWS, CONTACT US AT info@mashablepartners.com


©2025 TFI Media Private Limited

No Result
View All Result
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
TFIPOST हिन्दी
TFIPOST Global

©2025 TFI Media Private Limited