• Latest
  • Most Read
Swara Bhaskar Bhansali

A Response to Swara Bhaskar’s Unfair attack on Bhansali

5 years ago
Critics’ Choices: Overrated Indian Films that did not match up to the hype

Critics’ Choices: Overrated Indian Films that did not match up to the hype

11 hours ago
Indian actors you won’t believe weren’t the first choice for the classics

Indian actors you won’t believe weren’t the first choice for the classics

11 hours ago
“7 Indian Movies That Found an Audience, Despite Critic Rejections”

“7 Indian Movies That Found an Audience, Despite Critic Rejections”

17 hours ago
The Adipurush Controversy: Is it Time to Let the Audience Decide?

The Adipurush Controversy: Is it Time to Let the Audience Decide?

17 hours ago
Indian democracy

“Go and check out for yourselves”: White House’s stern message to rabble rousers on Indian democracy

17 hours ago
Indira Gandhi's assassination celebration

Ex Indian PM Indira Gandhi’s assassination is a matter of celebration in Canada

18 hours ago
Mobile Trading: Why Security and Privacy Should Be Your Top Priority

Mobile Trading: Why Security and Privacy Should Be Your Top Priority

1 day ago
Sam Pitroda issues Rahul Gandhi’s Report Card: FAIL

Sam Pitroda issues Rahul Gandhi’s Report Card: FAIL

2 days ago
Asur Season 2: Climax explained and the next series’ supervillain exposed!

Asur Season 2: Climax explained and the next series’ supervillain exposed!

2 days ago
Motilal was NRI. Patel was NRI. We are all NRIs, says Rahul Gandhi

Motilal was NRI. Patel was NRI. We are all NRIs, says Rahul Gandhi

2 days ago
Wrestlers Amit Shah meeting

One meeting with Amit Shah and the wrestlers protest dead

2 days ago
MOJO Story hacked

Barkha Dutt’s MOJO Story was not hacked. It was a digital victim card

2 days ago
BBC tax evasion

BBC tax evasion: Income Tax Department finally crushes BBC’s pride

3 days ago
Malini Parthasarathy resigns

Malini Parthasarathy resigns The Hindu, but with a departing salvo at N Ram

3 days ago
Bollywood remake

Bollywood films remade in various languages

3 days ago
  • About us
  • Careers
  • Brand Partnerships
TFI Official Merchandise
TFI हिन्दी
TFI Global
Friday, June 9, 2023
Tfipost.com
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
    Sam Pitroda issues Rahul Gandhi’s Report Card: FAIL

    Sam Pitroda issues Rahul Gandhi’s Report Card: FAIL

    Motilal was NRI. Patel was NRI. We are all NRIs, says Rahul Gandhi

    Motilal was NRI. Patel was NRI. We are all NRIs, says Rahul Gandhi

    Wrestlers Amit Shah meeting

    One meeting with Amit Shah and the wrestlers protest dead

    MOJO Story hacked

    Barkha Dutt’s MOJO Story was not hacked. It was a digital victim card

    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • All
    • Business
    • Economy1
    • Finance
    Mobile Trading: Why Security and Privacy Should Be Your Top Priority

    Mobile Trading: Why Security and Privacy Should Be Your Top Priority

    Report on India: Morgan Stanley gives double thumbs up to Modinomics

    Report on India: Morgan Stanley gives double thumbs up to Modinomics

    India's GDP

    Nominal GDP Growth at 16.1%? National Statistical Office releases India’s Economic accomplishment

    Vada Pav is Just the Tip of the Iceberg: A look into the rich culinary delights of Maharashtra

    India’s Resilience: A Zero Percent Chance of Recession

    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • All
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
    new CBI director Praveen sood biography

    Who is Praveen Sood the New CBI Director: Professional Background, Achievements and Significance of the Appointment

    Paramjit Singh Panjwar shot dead

    Paramjit Singh Panjwar shot dead: Keep calm and trust the Indian Armed Forces

    Swarm satellites

    India’s Bold Step towards Satellite Swarm Intelligence: A New Era in Space Technology

    INS Vikrant gets historic 1961 bell of 1st warship from ex-Navy vice chief

    INS Vikrant gets historic 1961 bell of 1st warship from ex-Navy vice chief

    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • All
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
    Indian democracy

    “Go and check out for yourselves”: White House’s stern message to rabble rousers on Indian democracy

    Indira Gandhi's assassination celebration

    Ex Indian PM Indira Gandhi’s assassination is a matter of celebration in Canada

    Modi is the boss

    Modi is the boss: “Vedic Mantras” and an ocean of crowd: PM Modi’s Australia tour will echo till eternity

    PM Modi Extends a Diplomatic Olive Branch: A Special Message for Zelensky

    PM Modi Extends a Diplomatic Olive Branch: A Special Message for Zelensky

    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • All
    • Culture
    • Education
    • History
    • Indology
    5 failed Inventions

    5 Inventions that failed to serve their purpose

    What Do You Mean by Bhulekh Uttar Pradesh & Why Should You use It?

    What Do You Mean by Bhulekh Uttar Pradesh & Why Should You use It?

    5 Accidental Inventions

    5 Accidental Inventions that have become essential in our lives

    Sengol Tamil Nadu real picture

    What is Sengol: Tamil Nadu Connection, History, Significance and why it is to be installed in New Parliament

    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • All
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Games
    • Health
    • Lifestyle
    • Satire
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    Critics’ Choices: Overrated Indian Films that did not match up to the hype

    Critics’ Choices: Overrated Indian Films that did not match up to the hype

    Indian actors you won’t believe weren’t the first choice for the classics

    Indian actors you won’t believe weren’t the first choice for the classics

    “7 Indian Movies That Found an Audience, Despite Critic Rejections”

    “7 Indian Movies That Found an Audience, Despite Critic Rejections”

    The Adipurush Controversy: Is it Time to Let the Audience Decide?

    The Adipurush Controversy: Is it Time to Let the Audience Decide?

    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
No Result
View All Result
Tfipost.com
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
    Sam Pitroda issues Rahul Gandhi’s Report Card: FAIL

    Sam Pitroda issues Rahul Gandhi’s Report Card: FAIL

    Motilal was NRI. Patel was NRI. We are all NRIs, says Rahul Gandhi

    Motilal was NRI. Patel was NRI. We are all NRIs, says Rahul Gandhi

    Wrestlers Amit Shah meeting

    One meeting with Amit Shah and the wrestlers protest dead

    MOJO Story hacked

    Barkha Dutt’s MOJO Story was not hacked. It was a digital victim card

    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • All
    • Business
    • Economy1
    • Finance
    Mobile Trading: Why Security and Privacy Should Be Your Top Priority

    Mobile Trading: Why Security and Privacy Should Be Your Top Priority

    Report on India: Morgan Stanley gives double thumbs up to Modinomics

    Report on India: Morgan Stanley gives double thumbs up to Modinomics

    India's GDP

    Nominal GDP Growth at 16.1%? National Statistical Office releases India’s Economic accomplishment

    Vada Pav is Just the Tip of the Iceberg: A look into the rich culinary delights of Maharashtra

    India’s Resilience: A Zero Percent Chance of Recession

    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • All
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
    new CBI director Praveen sood biography

    Who is Praveen Sood the New CBI Director: Professional Background, Achievements and Significance of the Appointment

    Paramjit Singh Panjwar shot dead

    Paramjit Singh Panjwar shot dead: Keep calm and trust the Indian Armed Forces

    Swarm satellites

    India’s Bold Step towards Satellite Swarm Intelligence: A New Era in Space Technology

    INS Vikrant gets historic 1961 bell of 1st warship from ex-Navy vice chief

    INS Vikrant gets historic 1961 bell of 1st warship from ex-Navy vice chief

    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • All
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
    Indian democracy

    “Go and check out for yourselves”: White House’s stern message to rabble rousers on Indian democracy

    Indira Gandhi's assassination celebration

    Ex Indian PM Indira Gandhi’s assassination is a matter of celebration in Canada

    Modi is the boss

    Modi is the boss: “Vedic Mantras” and an ocean of crowd: PM Modi’s Australia tour will echo till eternity

    PM Modi Extends a Diplomatic Olive Branch: A Special Message for Zelensky

    PM Modi Extends a Diplomatic Olive Branch: A Special Message for Zelensky

    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • All
    • Culture
    • Education
    • History
    • Indology
    5 failed Inventions

    5 Inventions that failed to serve their purpose

    What Do You Mean by Bhulekh Uttar Pradesh & Why Should You use It?

    What Do You Mean by Bhulekh Uttar Pradesh & Why Should You use It?

    5 Accidental Inventions

    5 Accidental Inventions that have become essential in our lives

    Sengol Tamil Nadu real picture

    What is Sengol: Tamil Nadu Connection, History, Significance and why it is to be installed in New Parliament

    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • All
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Games
    • Health
    • Lifestyle
    • Satire
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    Critics’ Choices: Overrated Indian Films that did not match up to the hype

    Critics’ Choices: Overrated Indian Films that did not match up to the hype

    Indian actors you won’t believe weren’t the first choice for the classics

    Indian actors you won’t believe weren’t the first choice for the classics

    “7 Indian Movies That Found an Audience, Despite Critic Rejections”

    “7 Indian Movies That Found an Audience, Despite Critic Rejections”

    The Adipurush Controversy: Is it Time to Let the Audience Decide?

    The Adipurush Controversy: Is it Time to Let the Audience Decide?

    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
No Result
View All Result
Tfipost.com
No Result
View All Result

HOME » Politics » Opinions » A Response to Swara Bhaskar’s Unfair attack on Bhansali

A Response to Swara Bhaskar’s Unfair attack on Bhansali

Avina Kohli
by Avina Kohli
28 January 2018
in Opinions
0
Swara Bhaskar Bhansali
61k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Dear Ms. Swara Bhaskar,

I read your meticulously written letter to Mr. Bhansali where you say that you felt reduced to a vagina “only” after watching his film Padmaavat. As much as I appreciate the effort that must have gone behind that rather long-ish letter, as an avid reader and someone who knows a thing or two about good writing, I think you could have done without all that repetition. Doing that might have created more space for substance. (Yes, I am assuming you had substance that you probably did not put because of the lack of space)

But Ms. Swara Bhaskar, this letter obviously is not about that; nor is it about our admiration for Mr. Bhansali and his art. Like you, I have always been fascinated by his creativity and the sheer beauty that his films are. Like you, I have also been vocal in defending ‘Padmavati’ albeit without a proof.

So when you wrote an open letter on a “reputed” (mind the quotes) online portal about Mr. Bhansali and Padmaavat-two of the things I care about, I felt it would be okay to tell you why whatever you said is not okay.

Ms. Swara Bhaskar, Before I go on to give you a lesson in history and explain the idea of ‘context’ and contextual approach, let us begin with the basics.

Ms. Swara Bhaskar, here is a very humble reminder that Mr. Bhansali is a filmmaker, an artist whose job is to make films, not give visual lectures in feminism. Mr. Bhansali will not spend 185 crores to make a film that appeals to your feminism.

As a proponent of free speech and expression, I have always felt that banning and blocking creative art is unjustified, equally unjustified is pointless criticism like your criticism of Mr. Bhansali for not making a film that fits your point of view and your idea of how a woman should think of her life.

Also, why put the onus on Mr. Bhansali? Given the resources that you have, how about coming out with a movie of your own, setting the narrative you want to set? Why should someone else’s hard work be subjected to criticism for not doing something that he did not intend doing anyway? Instead, how about doing on your own what you expect someone else to do and criticize him for not doing? Walk the talk, Ms. Bhaskar.

Ms. Swara Bhaskar, In your letter you complained to Mr Bhansali, that while watching the climax of the movie, you felt that your “existence was illegitimate…” and it was wrong of you “to choose life over death” and thus emphasizing on the impact and power of cinema. I want to ask you this, if a three-hour long film can make you question your beliefs or nudge you to feel in a way that is contrary to your beliefs, are your beliefs even your own?

Where is the conviction Ms. Swara Bhaskar, that does not alter even if the entire world opposes it? Where was the voice that says ‘eklacholo re’ and refuses to be bogged down by the society? For those of us who believe in the values we do, films and dramas cannot change it. The next time your feminist ideas and beliefs feel threatened, Mary Wollstonecraft, Virginia Woolf, Simon de Beauvoir, Saadat Hasan Manto, Ismat Chugtai are some writers whose works you could probably look at.

Also, if cinema is the way to eradicate all evils of the society, let us just do away with the art in cinema and have two movies for each evil and that should solve all the problems of the society.

Having established the basics, I will move on to tell you why you need to unlearn and relearn the idea of ‘context’. The contextual approach to interpretation which is a common theme within the liberal arts, asks that the work be studied along with the background and information about the time in which it was written. The contextual approach looks at things as part of a larger picture which includes the customs, rituals, accepted norms and the understanding of the creator, at the time of its creation. So Ms. Swara Bhaskar, no matter how much you pull and distort it to fit your version, the context of Padmaavat remains the 13th century and not the modern day India; your description of which is the “gang rape infested India”.  Your interpretation of Padmaavat is closer to a textual approach which takes the works as they are, focusing on the literal text without studying the time and background of their creation. So obviously, applying the wrong approach of interpretation to a historical fiction will give you the sort of flawed observations you have written about.

While the context of Padmaavat is not the “gang rape infested India, this rape condoning mindset, this victim blaming society”, the context of Raanjhanaa and Prem Ratan Dhan Payo is. These two of yourfilms set in the backdrop of modern day India are works you should have kept in mind before ranting about the impact of cinema. Raanjhanaa glorifies stalking and your character has been shown to be (hopelessly) in love with a stalker. You had a choice to say no to the film, instead you chose to do the film and write an oped justifying the film and years later you also spoke about it on Rajeev Masand’s 2017 Roundtable saying that you ‘did not see through it’. Did you also not see through Prem Ratan Dhan Payo and dialogues like “Ram jaisa chahenge, Sita waisa hi karegi”? Did you not think of the impact this will have on thousands of young girls in the country? This is why Ms. Bhaskar your letter reeks of a holier than thou attitude.

Here’s how you justified your balancing act:

I turn down vulgar film offers and fairness cream advertisements but there are times when I have to make compromises too. I definitely had a problem with the misogyny in my film Raanjhanaa and pointed that out to the writers. Even Prem Ratan Dhan Payo operated within a socially conservative world. But then I made up for it by doing Tanu Weds Manu.

 – Swara Bhaskar, The Hindu, March 26, 2016

That’s about 63 words for just 1 word – Hypocrisy.

Ms. Swara Bhaskar, allow me to point out the technical fallacy of your letter. Throughout the letter, you use Sati and Jauhar interchangeably. While sati was at times was forced on women, Jauhar was not forced. Jauhar, by definition, could not have been forced because it took place when all the men of the kingdom had died in the battleground. It was a choice that women made. The idea that there were women who chose death over a life of sexual servitude from which there was no escape seems beyond your understanding.

Do you really think the life of Sexual slave is better than death? Is breathing, eating, sleeping and then getting rampaged by a sexual predator every night is what you call life?

Do you know ‘Hundreds’ of Yazidi women have killed themselves in ISIS captivity? Do you consider them anti-feminist? Or Dishonorable Women or not women enough?

The fact that women can make choices that do not appeal and fit the modern day western feminist narrative is a concept that seems to evade most feminists today-in this case, you Ms. Swara Bhaskar.

The idea that a saree clad, culturally rooted woman who observes karwachauthas a choice can be a feminist by virtue of exercising equal rights and accepting equal responsibilities seems unfathomable to your ilk.

I understand how most of you dismiss this choice as ‘conditioning’. But please tell me why these choices are categorized as ‘patriarchal conditioning’ and the others as ‘enlightenment’?

Ms. Swara Bhaskar, I appreciate your concern about the condition of women and their safety in the country. But have ever thought about doing more than creating noise and being more than an armchair activist (as your Twitter handle describes you)? I have friends who work and live in remote areas of the country for education and upliftment; you could come and contribute. The people will not recognize you as a Bollywood actress because they do not have the resources to but you will surely learn a lesson or two in a type of feminism that is different from yours.

For me, you Ms. Swara Bhaskar are no different than Karni Sena (sans violence) insofar as you go around raising your voice because someone has not made a film showcasing your point of view or has made a film that is contrary to your understanding of ideas and events. You, Karni Sena and Mr. Bhansali- all of you are entitled to and justified in showcasing your opinions, understanding and its expression but what you and Karni Sena are not entitled to, is holding Mr. Bhansali accountable for having a view contrary to yours.

P.S: For future reference, here is a brief bit from history. Alauddin Khilji was barbaric invader, a pedophile who was known for his perverse sexual acts. Khilji’s harem was not a comfortable bedroom for women to lie down and enjoy their lives but the chamber of a demented mind, who was not looking forward to making love but brutalizing the women he won as spoils of war through his sexually perverse acts.

Tags: PadmaavatSanjay leela BhansaliSwara Bhaskar
Share6291TweetSend
Previous Post

Shastri – Officially a Burden on Team India!

Next Post

Muntra: Say Hello to Muntra, India’s first Unmanned tank

Avina Kohli

Avina Kohli

Political Science graduate. Thinker. Observer. Admirer of arts and all things beautiful.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms of use and Privacy Policy.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

  • Most Read
  • Comments
  • Latest
Xi Jinping, coronavirus, Shinzo Abe, china, Japan, coornavirus, COVID-19, Wuhan Virus

‘Pack up and get out of there,’ Japan to spend $2.2 billion to get Japanese companies to exit China

9 April 2020
ajay devgn karan johar

The man who bullied the Bully – How Ajay Devgn made Karan Johar’s monopoly a joke and forced him to apologize

22 June 2020
Huawei, China, Trump, USA, Xi Jinping

‘Our survival is at stake now,’ Chinese Telecom giant Huawei crumbles after US ban on Semiconductor exports

19 May 2020
T-Series Sonu Nigam Divya Khosla Kumar Bhushan Kumar

T-Series forced to take down Atif Aslam’s video, Divya Khosla trolled. T-Series has a bad day in office

25 June 2020
Meat Ban

A Jain responds to Meat Ban in Mumbai

Public Sector Bank, Government, Bill

Dear bank employees, continue your stride but PSBs will be privatized

anti-Hindi

Anti-Hindi Forever?- In search of a National Language!

Dear Liberals – your Beef Parties are not protests, they just intend to displease the Majority

Dear Liberals – your Beef Parties are not protests, they just intend to displease the Majority

Critics’ Choices: Overrated Indian Films that did not match up to the hype

Critics’ Choices: Overrated Indian Films that did not match up to the hype

8 June 2023
Indian actors you won’t believe weren’t the first choice for the classics

Indian actors you won’t believe weren’t the first choice for the classics

8 June 2023
“7 Indian Movies That Found an Audience, Despite Critic Rejections”

“7 Indian Movies That Found an Audience, Despite Critic Rejections”

8 June 2023
The Adipurush Controversy: Is it Time to Let the Audience Decide?

The Adipurush Controversy: Is it Time to Let the Audience Decide?

8 June 2023

Popular This Week

5 Actors who ruined a Franchise as Replacement
Cinema

5 Actors who ruined a Franchise as Replacement

by TFIPOST News Desk
2 June 2023
MOJO Story hacked
Analysis

Barkha Dutt’s MOJO Story was not hacked. It was a digital victim card

by Atul Kumar Mishra
6 June 2023
Sportspersons careers
Sports

5 Indian Sportspersons Who Destroyed Their Own Careers

by TFIPOST News Desk
2 June 2023
Wrestlers Protest
Politics

Modi govt. has done what it should have done a long ago with the Toolkit Gang

by Animesh Pandey
2 June 2023
Meet SP Singla, the “mastermind” of Bhagalpur collapse
Politics

Meet SP Singla, the “mastermind” of Bhagalpur collapse

by Animesh Pandey
5 June 2023

©2023 TFI Media Private Limited

  • Terms of use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
No Result
View All Result
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
TFI Official Merchandise
TFI हिन्दी
TFI Global
  • About us
  • Careers
  • Brand Partnerships

©2023 TFI Media Private Limited

Follow us on Twitter

and never miss an insightful take by the TFIPOST team

Follow @tfipost