TFIPOST हिन्दी
TFIPOST Global
Tfipost.com
Tfipost.com
No Result
View All Result
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
    Raj, Uddhav Push Marathi Agenda for Political Comeback

    Thackeray Cousins Reunite, Use Language Card to Stay Relevant in Maharashtra Politics

    Nehal Modi, brother of Nirav Modi arrested in US

    Nehal Modi, Brother of Nirav Modi, Arrested in U.S.; Extradition Proceedings Initiated

    Sydney Protest Sends Global Message Against Hindu Persecution in Bangladesh

    Sydney Protest Sends Global Message Against Hindu Persecution in Bangladesh

    Congress’s Bihar Outreach on Menstrual Hygiene Raises Questions Over Rahul Gandhi’s Political Branding

    Congress’ Bihar Outreach on Menstrual Hygiene Raises Questions Over Rahul Gandhi’s Political Branding

    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • All
    • Business
    • Economy1
    • Finance
    India’s Forex Reserves Surge Past $700 Billion

    India’s Forex Reserves Surge Past $700 Billion, Close to All-Time Record

    Why GST Search Is Essential For Compliance In Modern Enterprises

    Why GST Search Is Essential For Compliance In Modern Enterprises

    Improving Communication and Collaboration in Distributed Teams: Strategies for Indian Business Analysts

    Improving Communication and Collaboration in Distributed Teams: Strategies for Indian Business Analysts

    Why Every Modern Retail Shop Needs Reliable Billing Software Today

    Why Every Modern Retail Shop Needs Reliable Billing Software Today

    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • All
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
    Major Arms Seizure in Manipur Hill Districts

    Amid Ongoing Tensions, Security Operation Yields Major Arms Seizure in Manipur Hill Districts

    military reveals china-pakistan-turkey nexus during operation sindoor

    One Border, Three Adversaries: Indian Army Blasts China-Pakistan-Turkey Axis in Operation Sindoor

    INS Tamal marks the end of import of Indian Warships

    INS Tamal Marks End of Warship Imports as India Sets Sail on Atmanirbhar Bharat Path

    UK’s 5th-Gen F-35B Jet Grounded in Kerala Set to Be Airlifted After Weeks of Uncertainty

    UK’s 5th-Gen F-35B Jet Grounded in Kerala Set to Be Airlifted After Weeks of Uncertainty

    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • All
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
    Sydney Protest Sends Global Message Against Hindu Persecution in Bangladesh

    Sydney Protest Sends Global Message Against Hindu Persecution in Bangladesh

    PM Modi Receives Trinidad's Highest Civilian Honour, Lands in Argentina to Deepen Strategic Ties

    PM Modi Receives Trinidad’s Highest Civilian Honour, Lands in Argentina to Deepen Strategic Ties

    when gandhi's statue was removed in ghana

    When Mahatma Gandhi’s Statue Was Removed in Ghana for Being ‘Racist’

    Empower the Global South: PM Modi

    Time to Reshape Global Governance, Empower the Global South: PM Modi

    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • All
    • Culture
    • Education
    • History
    • Indology
    The Beginning of Devotion: History of the First Kanwar Yatra

    The Beginning of Devotion: History of the First Kanwar Yatra 

    Kanwar Yatra: Four Devotional Paths, One Divine Destination

    Kanwar Yatra: Four Devotional Paths, One Divine Destination

    char dham yatra suspended due to bad weather

    Uttarakhand Suspends Char Dham Yatra Due to Adverse Weather, Prioritizes Pilgrim Safety

    Sanatan Mahakumbh Event Scheduled at Patna’s Gandhi Maidan

    Sanatan Mahakumbh Event Scheduled at Patna’s Gandhi Maidan on July 6

    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • All
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Entertainment
    • Food
    • Games
    • Health
    • Lifestyle
    • Satire
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    India's Tour of Bangladesh Likely Postponed Amid Political Unrest

    India’s Tour of Bangladesh Likely Postponed Amid Political Unrest

    What Is The Best Way To Bet On Tennis?

    What Is The Best Way To Bet On Tennis?

    Pakistan Hockey Team Set to Visit India for Asia Cup 2025: First Time Since Operation Sindoor

    First Time Since Operation Sindoor ; Pakistan Hockey Team Set to Visit India for Asia Cup 2025

    Health Experts Reaffirm Covid Vaccine Safety

    Health Experts Reaffirm Covid Vaccine Safety Amid Concerns Over Sudden Cardiac Deaths

    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
Tfipost.com
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
    Raj, Uddhav Push Marathi Agenda for Political Comeback

    Thackeray Cousins Reunite, Use Language Card to Stay Relevant in Maharashtra Politics

    Nehal Modi, brother of Nirav Modi arrested in US

    Nehal Modi, Brother of Nirav Modi, Arrested in U.S.; Extradition Proceedings Initiated

    Sydney Protest Sends Global Message Against Hindu Persecution in Bangladesh

    Sydney Protest Sends Global Message Against Hindu Persecution in Bangladesh

    Congress’s Bihar Outreach on Menstrual Hygiene Raises Questions Over Rahul Gandhi’s Political Branding

    Congress’ Bihar Outreach on Menstrual Hygiene Raises Questions Over Rahul Gandhi’s Political Branding

    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • All
    • Business
    • Economy1
    • Finance
    India’s Forex Reserves Surge Past $700 Billion

    India’s Forex Reserves Surge Past $700 Billion, Close to All-Time Record

    Why GST Search Is Essential For Compliance In Modern Enterprises

    Why GST Search Is Essential For Compliance In Modern Enterprises

    Improving Communication and Collaboration in Distributed Teams: Strategies for Indian Business Analysts

    Improving Communication and Collaboration in Distributed Teams: Strategies for Indian Business Analysts

    Why Every Modern Retail Shop Needs Reliable Billing Software Today

    Why Every Modern Retail Shop Needs Reliable Billing Software Today

    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • All
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
    Major Arms Seizure in Manipur Hill Districts

    Amid Ongoing Tensions, Security Operation Yields Major Arms Seizure in Manipur Hill Districts

    military reveals china-pakistan-turkey nexus during operation sindoor

    One Border, Three Adversaries: Indian Army Blasts China-Pakistan-Turkey Axis in Operation Sindoor

    INS Tamal marks the end of import of Indian Warships

    INS Tamal Marks End of Warship Imports as India Sets Sail on Atmanirbhar Bharat Path

    UK’s 5th-Gen F-35B Jet Grounded in Kerala Set to Be Airlifted After Weeks of Uncertainty

    UK’s 5th-Gen F-35B Jet Grounded in Kerala Set to Be Airlifted After Weeks of Uncertainty

    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • All
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
    Sydney Protest Sends Global Message Against Hindu Persecution in Bangladesh

    Sydney Protest Sends Global Message Against Hindu Persecution in Bangladesh

    PM Modi Receives Trinidad's Highest Civilian Honour, Lands in Argentina to Deepen Strategic Ties

    PM Modi Receives Trinidad’s Highest Civilian Honour, Lands in Argentina to Deepen Strategic Ties

    when gandhi's statue was removed in ghana

    When Mahatma Gandhi’s Statue Was Removed in Ghana for Being ‘Racist’

    Empower the Global South: PM Modi

    Time to Reshape Global Governance, Empower the Global South: PM Modi

    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • All
    • Culture
    • Education
    • History
    • Indology
    The Beginning of Devotion: History of the First Kanwar Yatra

    The Beginning of Devotion: History of the First Kanwar Yatra 

    Kanwar Yatra: Four Devotional Paths, One Divine Destination

    Kanwar Yatra: Four Devotional Paths, One Divine Destination

    char dham yatra suspended due to bad weather

    Uttarakhand Suspends Char Dham Yatra Due to Adverse Weather, Prioritizes Pilgrim Safety

    Sanatan Mahakumbh Event Scheduled at Patna’s Gandhi Maidan

    Sanatan Mahakumbh Event Scheduled at Patna’s Gandhi Maidan on July 6

    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • All
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Entertainment
    • Food
    • Games
    • Health
    • Lifestyle
    • Satire
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    India's Tour of Bangladesh Likely Postponed Amid Political Unrest

    India’s Tour of Bangladesh Likely Postponed Amid Political Unrest

    What Is The Best Way To Bet On Tennis?

    What Is The Best Way To Bet On Tennis?

    Pakistan Hockey Team Set to Visit India for Asia Cup 2025: First Time Since Operation Sindoor

    First Time Since Operation Sindoor ; Pakistan Hockey Team Set to Visit India for Asia Cup 2025

    Health Experts Reaffirm Covid Vaccine Safety

    Health Experts Reaffirm Covid Vaccine Safety Amid Concerns Over Sudden Cardiac Deaths

    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
No Result
View All Result
Tfipost.com
Tfipost.com
No Result
View All Result
  • Premium
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Defense
  • Geopolitics
  • Knowledge
  • Law
  • Lounge

The voteshare/seats conundrum: A case for Mixed-Member Proportional System?

Robert Barker by Robert Barker
21 November 2015
in Opinions, TFIUvaach
The voteshare/seats conundrum: A case for Mixed-Member Proportional System?
Share on FacebookShare on X

The bizarre counting exercise for Bihar perpetuated by many media houses on the 8th of November might have seen many twists and turns, but at the end of it all, it was conclusively proven that the NDA was no match for the might of the Mahagathbandhan. Nitish Kumar has become the Chief Minister for the fifth time, with a 26 year old RJD scion as his running mate. The results are quite interesting, as the CM is from a party which does not have the highest number of seats (that honor goes to the RJD), and is only third overall in terms of the vote share. The BJP with the largest vote share, is left with a measly 50 odd seats. This is the third, almost consecutive election in the past year and a half (LS-2014, Delhi, Bihar), where the vagaries of the first-past-the-post (FPP) system have resulted in near-brutal majorities for the leading parties, but has also pretty much decimated the opposition. Both of these are questionable developments in a modern democracy, and wouldn’t have come to pass if the election system were far more reflective of the people’s mandate. Indeed, the only major countries still using FPP are India, Canada, the UK, and USA, with most other functioning democracies using a more proportional system, or a form of run-off voting. The question of electoral reforms has rarely included discussions on the actual voting system itself, and as far as this author is concerned, is something that needs to be corrected.

The Indian requirements:

RelatedPosts

Criticism rises against US amidst allegations of interference 

“Rahul Gandhi is PM Modi’s biggest TRP,” Mamata Banerjee’s latest jibe

Few hours of Amit Shah in Bihar is good rough to ruffle Mahagathbandhan

Load More

While the search for a new voting system might be construed as a considerable challenge; given the economic, social, and historical realities in India, one’s options are considerably reduced. For a new system to have any realistic chance of being accepted by the electorate, and to pass through parliament, it should try and fulfill, at the very least, the following three criteria:

  1. It should not be too complicated for the voter, and should not alter the logistics of elections drastically.
  2. It should not interfere with existing institutions, and must not alter the parliamentary nature of the Indian republic. Additionally, it should not rescind the idea of directly elected local representatives.
  3. It should try and ensure maximum proportionality.

Any proportional system that involves ranking candidates, such as the single transferable vote, is automatically ruled out. These criteria also rules out other majority systems such as the alternative vote, and a two-round system, as they are not proportional, too complicated to implement, and hard to reconcile with the Westminster system. A purely proportional system, where one just votes for a party, and then the party decides to send representatives according to an internal list, is also not acceptable as the voters have no say in who exactly represents them in parliament. One is thus finally left with a mixed-member proportional system, such as one followed in Germany and New Zealand, which combines the best features of both systems, and tries to minimize the negatives of both.

Mixed-Member Proportional System explained:

On voting day, when the voter goes to the voting booth, he/she has to cast two votes, one for a candidate (as always), but an additional vote to a party. When the votes for the candidates are counted, the person with the most number of votes gets elected to parliament, as is the case now. The votes cast to the party are used to determine the final composition of the house, with a closed party list used to fill up the remaining seats in a proportional way. In cases where a party ends up with more directly elected candidates than its vote share (so-called overhang seats), the house is simply expanded, and other parties get more seats to achieve proportionality. At no point are the directly elected candidates forced to give up their seats. One could also impose an additional vote share criteria (5% being the norm) for parties to qualify for any additional seats over their directly elected representatives.

Bihar-a test case:

It is interesting to consider how the composition of the current Bihar assembly would be right now within an Mixed-Member Proportional System. At the start, let us assume that all parties have the exact same number of seats as they do now in this election. This is not particularly scientific, but will do for illustrative purposes. For simplicity’s sake, we show only the alliances, and not the individual parties in this example:

PartySeats% of seats% of votes
MGB1787341.9
NDA582431.8
others7326.3

This table clearly illustrates the problem with the FPP system. The MGB has nearly 75% of the seats despite commanding only 41% of votes, while the non-MGB/non-NDA parties are an order of magnitude off from what they deserve. Interestingly, the NDA is relatively better represented, with the offset between seats and votes only about 8%.

Now, in a purely proportional system, the composition of the house would have been:

PartySeats% of seats% of votes
MGB10241.941.9
NDA7731.831.8
others6326.326.3

The MGB drops off seats considerably, while the non-MGB/non-BJP parties gain a substantial number of seats. While this might seem like a fractured mandate, politically speaking, the MGB is in a better position than the NDA to attract 19 more seats from the Others column. This system however does not take into account the 76 extra MLAs that the MGB won. Mixed-Member Proportional System accommodates these extra MLAs, and ensures proportionality at the same time. The house would therefore be:

PartySeats% of seats% of votes
MGB1784241.9
NDA1353231.8
Others1102626.3

Due to the substantial overhang in this election, the house expands from 243 seats to 423 in order to accommodate the extra directly-elected representatives of the MGB, and to ensure true proportionality. Though the MGB does not have a clear majority in this scenario, it is only 34 seats away from achieving one, and is the most realistic alliance that will form the Govt. in Bihar. In this example, the house seems to be quite bloated, which might raise some concerns about the system. This is largely due to our hypothetical assumption here that the alliances will retain all of their directly elected representatives as it stands in this particular election. In a true Mixed-Member Proportional System , this is unlikely to happen, and the overhang is typically of the order of 15-20 seats at the most. Moreover, we have not considered a minimum threshold for parties to return party-list seats to the assembly, which would once again reduce the number of seats than what is shown here.

A constant criticism of proportional systems is that they never ensure a majority for any party, and would always result in coalition governments. Leaving aside the question of propriety of having a Govt. that is supported by a minority of the electorate (as is normally the case in a multi-party polity), this is a genuine concern in India, and could be catastrophic for the passage of legislation, and for ensuring a stable Govt. for five years. One way of sorting this out in an Mixed-Member Proportional System, is to bring the under-represented parties to the numbers they would have had in the original composition of the house, but allow the overhang. To put it in numbers for this particular election:

PartySeats% of seats% of votes
MGB1785641.9
NDA772431.8
Others632026.3

 

In this hypothetical scenario, the house expands to 318 seats, with the MGB emerging as the clear winner, but with a reduced percentage of seats. True proportionality is not achieved, but a much better representation of the voters’ will is achieved here than in FPP, without sacrificing stability. In a wave election where the largest party has a substantial plurality, but not a majority (as was witnessed in Bihar, Delhi, and the LS polls), this version of the system will always ensure a clear winner, but will prevent brutal majorities, and a more empowered opposition than in FPP.

The political context of Mixed-Member Proportional System :

For Mixed-Member Proportional System to have a realistic chance of ever being adopted by parliament, it needs to be attractive to a majority of political parties. The party that would benefit the most from Mixed-Member Proportional System would be the BJP, which despite commanding up to 30% of the votes in its strong states, still ends up performing badly due to the vagaries of the FPP system. Indeed, the only time where the BJP benefited from FPP was in LS-2014, where despite winning only a plurality of the votes, ended up with a majority on its own due to the division of the anti-BJP votes, a blue-moon event that is unlikely to repeat itself in 2019, even if it ends up winning that election. The Congress is also sure to benefit from the Mixed-Member Proportional System , and return more seats than it has in recent times, thanks to a large number of loyal voters in most states. Regional parties such as the BSP which have done poorly in recent elections, despite commanding a committed chunk of voters, will also do much better in an Mixed-Member Proportional System. The only parties that might see their returns take a turn for the worse are those that have less than a 10% vote share, and depend on vote division to win a few seats in the assembly. At least to his author, there does not seem to be a major negative for most parties to shift towards Mixed-Member Proportional System , especially since nearly all of them have borne the brunt of being decimated in wave elections in the recent past, and this system would have brought their final tally to something more respectable than it stands now.

Considering the challenges involved in changing to a new voting system, Mixed-Member Proportional System would have to be introduced in a phased manner, ideally for local body elections first, followed by a few states, and then for parliamentary polls. This is a process that is sure to take a decade or two, but it will give the EC enough time to educate the electorate (and study any problems with the system), and for the average voter to adjust to the new system.

Whether the Mixed-Member Proportional System (or an alternative system) would come to pass is open to speculation. Nevertheless, it is important to start discussing this issue that few have addressed since the formation of the Indian Union, if one is to ensure a truly modern democracy for the 21st century.

Tags: first-past-the-postIndia ElectionsMahagathbandhanMixed-Member Proportional SystemMMP
ShareTweetSend
Previous Post

Four of the Best Stock Tips for First Time Investors

Next Post

Vellapally Natesan, a rare Malyalee, who believes it’s his karma to unite Hindus in Kerala

Related Posts

way ahead of G7 summit
Opinions

When The Summit Became A Stage: The G7, Trump’s Exit, And Fractured World

17 June 2025

In the crisp alpine air of Kananaskis, nestled amidst the brooding Rockies of Alberta, world leaders gathered to forge...

The Tale of how Operation Sindoor Silenced Satyapal Malik and His Echo Chamber
Opinions

Operation Sindoor Success: Satyapal Malik and ilks disappears into abyss of silence

8 May 2025

On May 6, former Jammu and Kashmir Governor Satyapal Malik appeared in a much-publicised interview with controversial journalist Karan...

Operation Sindoor
Defense

Why Operation Sindoor? Because No One Touches the Sindoor of an Indian Woman Without Consequence

7 May 2025

In a rapid and decisive response to the Pahalgam Islamist attack that claimed the lives of 26 innocent tourists...

Load More

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms of use and Privacy Policy.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Currently Playing

Rage on stage: why a police officer resigned quit after CM's outburst

Rage on stage: why a police officer resigned quit after CM's outburst

00:03:40

Right to religion vs duty to identify: where should India draw the line?

00:04:34

Junior Kharge Calls to Ban RSS Amid Karnataka Congress Civil War!

00:10:02

Kerala Muslim Groups oppose Zumba classes for School Children

00:07:21

Crash or sabotage? Aviation expert on ahmedabad plane crash probe.

00:13:37
Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube
tfipostTfipost.com
Right Wing | News Analysis | Indian Opinion
  • About us
  • Careers
  • Brand Partnerships
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap

©2025 TFI Media Private Limited

No Result
View All Result
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
TFIPOST हिन्दी
TFIPOST Global

©2025 TFI Media Private Limited