USCIRF chair Asif Mahmood has accused India’s government of persecuting Muslims through its voter-roll revision. His credibility to make that charge is now in question, and the facts on the rolls do not fit the story he is telling.
Mahmood said “The Indian gov’t is targeting Muslim citizens by removing them from voter rolls, calling them ‘foreigners,’ and now illegally deporting them.” The commission’s post also said Home Minister Amit Shah had called India’s Muslims “infiltrators” who must be expelled.
The revision is large. It removed 130 million names, the largest deletion of voters in India’s history. The Election Commission says it removed duplicate, dead, shifted and ineligible voters, and that anyone wrongly excluded can appeal.
Hindu voters were hit too
Mahmood presents this as a purge of Muslims, but Hindu voters lost their place on the rolls in the millions. In West Bengal, about 63 percent of the deleted names were Hindus and 34 percent were Muslims. Hindus also made up large numbers of the deleted in Matua-dominated border areas of North 24 Parganas and Nadia. A chairman who ignores this is not describing an electoral exercise. He is pushing a narrative.
The 2017 post
A screenshot circulating online shows a 2017 post from the @DrMahmood40 account. It says Pakistan was founded on Islam, should stay under Muslim rulers, and should give “no breath to Sikhs and Hindus.” Indian outlet OpIndia has reproduced the same text and used it to accuse him of hypocrisy.
If the post is his, it is disqualifying. A man who wrote that about Hindus and Sikhs cannot credibly present himself as a defender of minority rights, and he cannot lecture India about its minorities. Mahmood has not answered for it in anything I found. He should say plainly whether he wrote it, and USCIRF should say whether it knew when it put him in charge.
A pattern of targeting India
The voter-roll charge is the latest in a long run of attacks on India under his chairmanship. USCIRF has urged targeted sanctions against the RSS, and the Hindu nationalist outlet Organiser has accused him of cordial high-level ties with Pakistan and a deliberate propaganda campaign against India. Those are Organiser’s allegations, not established facts.
The commission’s recommendations are not binding, and Washington has not acted on its recent India recommendations. New Delhi has repeatedly rejected USCIRF’s criticism, with the Ministry of External Affairs earlier calling one of its reports “malicious.”

































