TFIPOST हिन्दी
TFIPOST Global
Tfipost.com
Tfipost.com
No Result
View All Result
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
    Udit Raj Wants Astronauts Chosen by Caste

    Congress Leader Udit Raj’s ‘Dalit Astronaut’ Comment Reduces Space Mission to Caste Politics

    Is Congress Using 'Rohith Vemula Bill' to Smuggle Muslims into SC Quota?

    Is Congress Using ‘Rohith Vemula Bill’ to Sneak Muslims into SC Quota At the Cost of Hindu Dalits?

    Kerala Nurse’s Life in Balance: Can Yemen Accept India’s Blood Money Offer?

    Nimisha Priya’s Execution Put on Hold amid ongoing negotiations in Yemen

    gujarat plane crash

    Air India Crash Report Prompts Reckless Speculation, Undermining Credibility of Pilots: Claims Pilots Body

    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • All
    • Business
    • Economy1
    • Finance
    India Achieves 50% Non-Fossil Fuel Power Capacity

    India Achieves 50 pc Non-Fossil Fuel Power Capacity, Five Years Ahead of Schedule

    Advantages of Using an EMI Calculator Before Applying for a Personal Loan

    Advantages of Using an EMI Calculator Before Applying for a Personal Loan

    WiseProfitWay.com reviews – Trading Times

    WiseProfitWay.com reviews – Trading Times

    TheGenInfinity.com reviews – Account Types

    TheGenInfinity.com reviews – Account Types

    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • All
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
    India Set to Test ET-LDHCM: Hypersonic Missile

    India Tests Hypersonic Missile Aimed at Covering All of Pakistan and Key Chinese Military Zones

    India Conducts Successful Trial of Astra Missile

    India Conducts Successful Trial of Astra Missile BVRAAM Featuring Indigenous RF Seeker

    India Must Stay Vigilant as Turkey-Pakistan Axis Grows

    Pakistan and Turkey Deepen Anti-India Axis Through Defence, Radicalization Nexus

    14+ Nations Want BrahMos After Watching India’s Might in Operation Sindoor, Says Rajnath Singh

    BrahMos Missile Shines in Op Sindoor ;15 Countries Eye Deal, Reveals Rajnath Singh

    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • All
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
    Non-veg milk a red line in India-US trade talks. Here's why

    No Dairy Deal with US if Cows Are Fed Meat: India Stands Firm

    Half of Bangladeshi Girls Forced Into Child Marriage, UN Report

    Half of Bangladeshi Girls Forced Into Child Marriage, UN Report

    Hindu Faith Targeted Again in Canada: Eggs Thrown at Lord Jagannath’s Rath Yatra

    Hindu Faith Targeted Again in Canada: Eggs Thrown at Lord Jagannath’s Rath Yatra

    Pahalgam Terror Attack Backed by Pakistan’s Political and Military Leadership, Comparable to 26/11, Says Report

    Pahalgam Terror Attack Backed by Pakistan’s Political, Military Leadership, Comparable to 26/11, Says Report

    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • All
    • Culture
    • Education
    • History
    • Indology
    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    Echoes of the Cholas in Today’s Bharat

    Conqueror of the Seas: Rajendra Chola and the Rise of Naval Bharat

    The Pride of Maratha Power Gets UNESCO Tag

    From Raigad to Suvarnadurg: The Pride of Maratha Power Gets UNESCO Tag

    Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams Suspends Senior Official for Attending Church Services

    Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams Suspends Senior Official for Attending Church Services

    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • All
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Entertainment
    • Food
    • Games
    • Health
    • Lifestyle
    • Satire
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    resh Nipah Death in Kerala’s Palakkad Raises Statewide Alarm

    Nipah Scare Returns to Kerala: Second Death Leads to High Alert in Six Districts

    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    5 Places in India to Deepen Your Yoga Journey

    Discover Inner Peace: 5 Places in India to Deepen Your Yoga Journey

    Khalistani Terrorist Pannun Threatens Kapil Sharma

    Khalistani Terrorist Pannun Threatens Kapil Sharma: ‘Why Are You Investing In Canada?’

    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
Tfipost.com
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
    Udit Raj Wants Astronauts Chosen by Caste

    Congress Leader Udit Raj’s ‘Dalit Astronaut’ Comment Reduces Space Mission to Caste Politics

    Is Congress Using 'Rohith Vemula Bill' to Smuggle Muslims into SC Quota?

    Is Congress Using ‘Rohith Vemula Bill’ to Sneak Muslims into SC Quota At the Cost of Hindu Dalits?

    Kerala Nurse’s Life in Balance: Can Yemen Accept India’s Blood Money Offer?

    Nimisha Priya’s Execution Put on Hold amid ongoing negotiations in Yemen

    gujarat plane crash

    Air India Crash Report Prompts Reckless Speculation, Undermining Credibility of Pilots: Claims Pilots Body

    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • All
    • Business
    • Economy1
    • Finance
    India Achieves 50% Non-Fossil Fuel Power Capacity

    India Achieves 50 pc Non-Fossil Fuel Power Capacity, Five Years Ahead of Schedule

    Advantages of Using an EMI Calculator Before Applying for a Personal Loan

    Advantages of Using an EMI Calculator Before Applying for a Personal Loan

    WiseProfitWay.com reviews – Trading Times

    WiseProfitWay.com reviews – Trading Times

    TheGenInfinity.com reviews – Account Types

    TheGenInfinity.com reviews – Account Types

    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • All
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
    India Set to Test ET-LDHCM: Hypersonic Missile

    India Tests Hypersonic Missile Aimed at Covering All of Pakistan and Key Chinese Military Zones

    India Conducts Successful Trial of Astra Missile

    India Conducts Successful Trial of Astra Missile BVRAAM Featuring Indigenous RF Seeker

    India Must Stay Vigilant as Turkey-Pakistan Axis Grows

    Pakistan and Turkey Deepen Anti-India Axis Through Defence, Radicalization Nexus

    14+ Nations Want BrahMos After Watching India’s Might in Operation Sindoor, Says Rajnath Singh

    BrahMos Missile Shines in Op Sindoor ;15 Countries Eye Deal, Reveals Rajnath Singh

    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • All
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
    Non-veg milk a red line in India-US trade talks. Here's why

    No Dairy Deal with US if Cows Are Fed Meat: India Stands Firm

    Half of Bangladeshi Girls Forced Into Child Marriage, UN Report

    Half of Bangladeshi Girls Forced Into Child Marriage, UN Report

    Hindu Faith Targeted Again in Canada: Eggs Thrown at Lord Jagannath’s Rath Yatra

    Hindu Faith Targeted Again in Canada: Eggs Thrown at Lord Jagannath’s Rath Yatra

    Pahalgam Terror Attack Backed by Pakistan’s Political and Military Leadership, Comparable to 26/11, Says Report

    Pahalgam Terror Attack Backed by Pakistan’s Political, Military Leadership, Comparable to 26/11, Says Report

    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • All
    • Culture
    • Education
    • History
    • Indology
    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    Echoes of the Cholas in Today’s Bharat

    Conqueror of the Seas: Rajendra Chola and the Rise of Naval Bharat

    The Pride of Maratha Power Gets UNESCO Tag

    From Raigad to Suvarnadurg: The Pride of Maratha Power Gets UNESCO Tag

    Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams Suspends Senior Official for Attending Church Services

    Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams Suspends Senior Official for Attending Church Services

    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • All
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Entertainment
    • Food
    • Games
    • Health
    • Lifestyle
    • Satire
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    resh Nipah Death in Kerala’s Palakkad Raises Statewide Alarm

    Nipah Scare Returns to Kerala: Second Death Leads to High Alert in Six Districts

    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    5 Places in India to Deepen Your Yoga Journey

    Discover Inner Peace: 5 Places in India to Deepen Your Yoga Journey

    Khalistani Terrorist Pannun Threatens Kapil Sharma

    Khalistani Terrorist Pannun Threatens Kapil Sharma: ‘Why Are You Investing In Canada?’

    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
No Result
View All Result
Tfipost.com
Tfipost.com
No Result
View All Result
  • Premium
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Defense
  • Geopolitics
  • Knowledge
  • Law
  • Lounge

Is Devdutt Pattanaik really a scholar or an overrated Pop-Mythologist?

Kapil Routray by Kapil Routray
12 January 2017
in Culture
devdutt pattanaik

Image Courtesy: The Hungry Reader, Wordpress

Share on FacebookShare on X

Almost all modern Indologists, all modern Indian education, all modern Indian religion is looked upon from an explicitly and unabashedly Semitic or Abrahamic point of view, arising from the Colonial superstructure of our Intelligentsia. Further- since admittance to the Intelligentsia is entirely dependent on toeing the line on such matters, scholars often end up pigeonholing themselves into the same Semitic worldview- just to fit into the Mainstream.

Devdutt Pattanaik is just another example of this.

RelatedPosts

Sahitya Akademi ‘postpones’ seminar after drawing ire for inviting ‘mythologists’ Devdutt Pattanaik, Namita Gokhale

How is Devdutt Pattanaik a youth icon? We fail to understand!

‘Rape is accepted in Hinduism,’ Devdutt Pattanaik hits the lowest of the lows in his new article

Load More

Pattanaik has been a fixture on the Indian pop-mythology scene for the better part of two decades. Indeed, he has been Indian pop-mythology for the better part of two decades. As such, he has done almost irreparable damage to the way lots of Indians view their past and their culture. The key reasons for this are three-fold, all emerging from trying to squeeze an Indo-European worldview into a Semitic mould:-

Modernization:

Again and again and again, Indologists and pop-mythologists insist upon not only standing judgement on the ancestors of modern Indians but doing so in mock trials where modern Indians are denied even a defence. Consider the recent events of the past few days- sparked of when Mr Devdutt Pattanaik went on a tirade against Brahmins based on the persecution allegedly faced by the Marathi poet Dnyaneshwara and the Oriya poet Balarama Das. Of course- the fact that both wrote in their native languages, both were Brahmins themselves, and both got no small amount of support from the existing government structure- which included Brahmins as well- goes unsaid. Further in the course of his books, Mr Devdutt Pattanaik appears to consider Marxist-Liberal theories as a vital yardstick to judge the actions of Arya heroes.

The problems with this are several.

Firstly- the criticisms are mostly based on baseless, if not entirely erroneous, readings altogether. It is common knowledge that most modern Indologists and eminent historians have little knowledge of Sanskrit or other Classical languages such as Suraseni. Such was on full display at the end of Mr Pattanaik’s recent Twitter meltdown where Mr Nityanand Misra, an IIMB alumni who is also a Sanskritist and Author, demonstrated the fallacious translations done by Mr Devdutt Pattanaik in his recent works.

The consequences of this are severe. What Mr Pattanaik appears to have done is to beef up his limited Sanskrit knowledge with copious amounts of third-party translations and English transliterations. As such- he falls in the trap even Seventeenth century scholars like the legendary Willian Jones or general Charles Stuart cautioned the first generation of Indologists against- seeing truth in propaganda. In his works, Mr Devdutt Pattanaik is clearly borrowing from the pop-culture of Buddhism (more on the term later). He clearly attributes to the Buddha the concepts of Monasticism, Asceticism, and the usual pop-culture view on non-violence, women’s rights, and anti-casteism. All this is incorrect- though this is neither the time nor place for a full explanation.

Secondly- It is not uncommon to find ‘Indologists’ butchering Indian texts into nonsense. Consider the so-called Manu Smriti, well hated by Liberal and Ambedkarites. Not one of these people have read the work; I guarantee it. If readers take a look, they’ll find that the text is hodgepodge of self-contradictory, chaotic, and nonsensical doctrines without any organization or reason.

What the Manu Smriti was, in fact, was a collection of texts drawn from a vast chunk of North India, centred on Lucknow and Calcutta, and compiled and translated haphazardly by British government and Company scholars. It is no surprise that the greatest contributor to Indology would be a German, Max Muller, and semi-independent William Jones, part of Dr Johnson’s club. To look upon the entire corpus of Arya literature- written over a massive swathe of human history from as early as the third millennia BC to the fifth century CE- and lump it into a set of persistent tautologies based on erroneous translations is an absurdity of the highest order- and yet, Mr Pattanaik manages to accomplish it.

One can almost imagine Mr Devdutt Pattanaik comparing and contrasting the clean lines of Biblical literature with that of the multifarious, multiple lines of Indian literature and grimacing in frustration. Readers need only look at his talk on Greek and India literature in order to get a sense of this; Mr Pattanaik clearly finds Greek religious literature- butchered and chopped up in easily-digestible blocks by centuries of Christianization- a far more topic to handle than the multi-headed hydra that is Arya thought.

Lastly- such criticism is not logical, let alone practical, to consider the actions of Classical or pre-Classical societies on the yardstick of the present. No other peoples in the World do so- save Indians. You will never find Chinese scholars filling up vast books on the slave trade in their lands. Nor will you find European historians ranting incessantly on the witch-burnings there. But it is Indians and Indians alone who would harp on the alleged faults of the Arya way of life and tolerate eminent historians like Dr Wendy Doniger calling works like the Bhagavad Gita, ‘violent’.

All cultures are to be looked upon in the proper timeframe; what persons like Mr Devdutt Pattanaik have done is to infantilize, nay- ignore- all of Indian history in favour of harping upon a set of pet grievances. As a result, we have an incredible situation at present where all the names universally acknowledged as the greatest in Indology belong to those dead for decades, if not centuries. Why break one’s back trying to uncover lost Haryanka palaces when one can mention yet another ‘re-imagination’ of Draupadi?

Doctrinilization:

There is the Ramayana- the version said to have been penned by Valmiki- and there are Ramayanas- the Kamban Ramayana, the Javanese Ramayana, the Oriya Ramayana, etc. The logical answer would be to read all, present the Valmiki Ramayana, and elaborate on the others separately. Instead- Mr Pattanaik combines them all into… something… with often, hilarious results.

Consider this- the Valmiki Ramayana features a Hanuman who is a celibate, stoic and grim ascetic. The Javanese Hanuman is the product of centuries of cross pollination from both the Indian accounts of Hanuman- as well as the Chinese interpretations of Hanuman that had flown into the country from India centuries ago and merged with local legends of monkey lords- thus, producing a happy-go-lucky womanizing and cheerful warlord. Mr Pattanaik has tried to combine both versions into one characters in Sita- and made a mess of both.

This is not all.

The current pop-culture version of Buddhism we have in India is heavily based on- to be honest- daydreams by British Indologist Alexander Cunningham and carried forward by Dr Ambedkar. It has little, probably nothing, to do with the Buddhism preached by the Buddha himself- or the Buddhism of the Great Councils, or that of the Mahasiddhas of Classical India. Indeed- the term ‘Buddhism’ itself is meaningless since the idea of organized religion per se, to refer to the works of Dr Reza Arslan, is a Christian concept that began with Paul of Tarsus.

What did exist in India was, instead, a school of philosophy- much like hundreds of others. Early ‘Buddhists’- if the term can even be used- worshipped the same gods, followed similar social customs, and maintained very similar doctrines as the scholars of the Ajivikas, the Jainas, the Samanas, or those in the footsteps of more ‘extreme’ philosophers such as the Keshakamabali. Even to this day, Kubera- god of wealth for the Aryas- is worshipped as a war god in Japan, a state of affairs that would be utterly unexplainable to anyone if we went by the teachings of eminent historians and pop-mythologists.

Thus, we find that Mr Devdutt Pattanaik ’s popular works- commonly passed off as works of scholarship- are the equivalent of complete gibberish.

Mr Pattanaik bases the characters of his fictions- aye, they are fictions and have little to do with Indian religious texts- on multiple adaptations done over the millennia by multiple cultures, with no rhyme or reason to the entire exercise. While he does provide a few footnotes which might help a reader to understand what he is doing, the truth pf the matter remains that the final works penned by Mr Pattanaik are not only jarring to read and confusing- but also provide a false view of Aryanism per se.

Coupled with this is the unfortunate fact that we have already stated- Mr Pattanaik has no real knowledge of Sanskrit and other Classical languages. Thus, we find that the errors in Mr Pattanaik’s works are so many and so fundamental that it puts rather a dark pall on his claims of being an expert on Vedic culture.

It is this which lies at the heart of the conflicts between Mr Devdutt Pattanaik and several new ‘Hindu’ historians and writers such as Mr Rajiv Malhotra- apart from the rather damning claims of plagiarism that have only grown more and more disturbing over the years.

Which leads us to wonder- why Mr Pattanaik enjoys such popularity over other competing writers and thinkers? Surely it is not a matter of scholarship; for there are greater thinkers than him especially since a no-namer like I can easily poke holes into his works. Neither is it a matter of presentation for the average young educated Indian is, at heart, a very uncreative individual who can be swayed easily by even the pettiest of words. Neither is it a question of intellectual integrity- as anyone can see.

Infantilization:

Modern Indologist are a fascinating type of creature who will not be able to tell you the name of their great-grandfathers or the name of their own city’s founder- but have no compunctions about holding court on events that happened 6000 years ago or more. For some fascinating reason, Indian academia feels it justified to dismiss the entire 1200 year long stretch we call ‘Classical India’- when Indian cultures, sciences, military might, and technology saw its greatest flowering- and instead, obsesses incessantly on the what colour the horses of their mythical Aryans were when they came riding into the Continent.

This Marxist view of history flows into the narrative of a divided India, fit only to be ruled by ancestors.

Indian history, therefore, ceases to be an arena where we can explore the truths of how we became what we are. Instead it serves primarily as a denial of what we are. From worshipping our ancestors as the Aryas once did, we have now denigrated into scum who must mock them and deny them at every stage- lest we lose the tag of being ‘modern’.

Hang shoes on statues of Maryada Purushottam Rama! He is an Aryan patriarchal bigot!

Boycott Raksha Bandhan! It is oppression by brothers upon sisters!

Ban Jallikattu! It is animal cruelty!

All are lies- and yet, thanks to pop-mythologists and eminent historians, they are reported ad nauseum. If Mr Pattanaik is the face of pop-mythologists today, why is he even calling himself a champion of Indian ‘mythology’?

Mr Devdutt Pattanaik’s views in support of the eminent historians who peddle the absurd Aryan invasion lie and his hatred for the few Western Indologists- such as Dr Danino and Dr Elst- who do write in support of true Indian history ought to serve to bar him outright from penning a word on Indian culture and history in general.

Instead it is matter of shame that such individuals are glorified beyond measure, called to lecture similar money-obsessed youth on how they should hate themselves and their fellow Indians, and plagiarize texts from better thinkers and scholars. Clearly the society that allows this travesty is verifiably nuts. When we look at the posh glitterati of India’s metros mock the ‘cattle class’, when we see entire States under siege in the east and the south, when we see empty-headed morons peddle lies like the Aryan-Dravidian myth, when we see scam worth thousands of crores one in broad daylight, there is no other explanation for the current events.

Whom the gods wish to destroy, they first cause to go insane… as was said of King Dhritarashtra in the Mahabharata. Let’s hope Mr Pattanaik sees fit to mention this to his bull-headed charges one day.

Tags: Devdutt PattanaikIndologists
Share2TweetSend
Previous Post

West Bengal’s intellect and Kerala’s literacy – Are they really what they claim?

Next Post

How Ramakrishna Mission betrayed Swami Vivekanda and Hindus?

Related Posts

Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic
Books

Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

14 July 2025

In the vast ocean of India’s civilizational treasures, few texts evoke as much passion, controversy, and confusion as the...

The Pride of Maratha Power Gets UNESCO Tag
Culture

From Raigad to Suvarnadurg: The Pride of Maratha Power Gets UNESCO Tag

12 July 2025

On a quiet July evening, the hearts of many in Maharashtra and across India, beat a little louder, filled...

Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams Suspends Senior Official for Attending Church Services
Culture

Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams Suspends Senior Official for Attending Church Services

9 July 2025

The Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams (TTD), the governing body of the world-renowned Tirumala temple, has suspended one of its senior...

Load More

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms of use and Privacy Policy.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Currently Playing

Bhima Koregaon Won’t Be Repeated; Maharashtra’s Special Act to Wipe Out Urban Naxals.

Bhima Koregaon Won’t Be Repeated; Maharashtra’s Special Act to Wipe Out Urban Naxals.

00:06:06

Conqueror of the Seas: Rajendra Chola and the Rise of Naval Bharat

00:07:47

How UPI went global? Why Namibia Adopted It?

00:07:20

Stalin’s DMK Faces Heat Over Brutal Custodial Killings in Tamil Nadu

00:08:06

Hindu girl r@ped, burned with cigarettes and forced to convert to Islam

00:03:31
Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube
tfipostTfipost.com
Right Wing | News Analysis | Indian Opinion
  • About us
  • Careers
  • Brand Partnerships
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
MASHABLE IS A GLOBAL, MULTI-PLATFORM MEDIA AND ENTERTAINMENT COMPANY. FOR MORE QUERIES AND NEWS, CONTACT US AT info@mashablepartners.com


©2025 TFI Media Private Limited

No Result
View All Result
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
TFIPOST हिन्दी
TFIPOST Global

©2025 TFI Media Private Limited