The Academy Awards, also known as the Oscars, have long been revered as the ultimate recognition for excellence in filmmaking. However, throughout its history, there have been instances where the choice for Best Picture left audiences and critics scratching their heads. Here are 11 movies that, despite winning the prestigious Oscar, are still considered the worst choices for Best Picture:
The Greatest Show on Earth [1952]:
Cecil B. DeMille’s circus spectacle may have impressed with its scale, but its formulaic plot and lack of depth made it an underwhelming choice. The fact that it won over the iconic “Singin’ in the Rain” raises eyebrows to this day.
Bridge on the River Kwai [1957]:
One cannot help but scratch their heads over this weird choice for the Best Picture. In a year, with classics like “12 Angry Men” and “The Throne of Blood” [one of the greatest masterpieces on Macbeth], how did a rather average flick like “Bridge on the River Kwai” won the award is a mystery to many.
Also read: Captivating Cinema: 10 Must Watch Films of Cate Blanchett
Gandhi [1982]:
As an Indian, one must admit that this is not the glory one would have wanted for India. No doubt that Ben Kingsley gave one of his greatest performances as Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi, but that didn’t mean that “Gandhi” deserved the “Best Picture”, especially with flicks like “ET”, “Tootsie” in the fray.
Out of Africa [1985]:
This visually stunning romantic drama set in colonial Africa received accolades for its grandeur. Nevertheless, critics argued that its slow pacing and lack of compelling storytelling made it an unworthy winner over “The Color Purple.”
Driving Miss Daisy [1988]:
This heartwarming tale of an African-American chauffeur and his elderly employer touched many hearts. However, its safe and predictable storytelling left some feeling it was a safe choice compared to Spike Lee’s powerful “Do the Right Thing.”
Forrest Gump [1994]:
Now the Tom Hanks starrer wasn’t exactly a bad or overrated movie. But in a year, with classics like “Pulp Fiction”, “The Shawshank Redemption”, even “True Lies” to an extent, awarding “Forrest Gump” with the top honors isn’t exactly the best decision.
Shakespeare in Love [1998]:
However, this was only the beginning. Academy had its own “Gully Boy” moments, where they awarded films that didn’t even merit a nomination, forget the “Best Picture”. Despite giving it his all in “Saving Private Ryan”, one of the greatest war dramas of all time, Steven Spielberg was literally robbed of the top honors, as a rather questionable “Shakespeare in Love” was accorded the top honors.
Chicago [2002]:
This musical adaptation garnered attention for its flashy dance numbers and star-studded cast. However, its lack of emotional depth and stiff competition from “The Pianist” and “The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers” made it a questionable winner.
Crash [2004]:
This controversial drama tackled issues of racial tension in Los Angeles. While it sparked important discussions, many critics argued that it presented an oversimplified and superficial examination of complex themes. The film’s win over more deserving contenders like “Brokeback Mountain” remains a contentious point of debate.
Also read: Why Warner Bros and Disney failed in India
Slumdog Millionaire [2008]:
“Slumdog Millionaire” garnered widespread acclaim and won the Best Picture Oscar, but it was considered by some as overrated. While the film showcased vibrant visuals and a compelling rags-to-riches story, critics argued it relied on clichés and poverty porn tropes, presenting an outsider’s view of India. Additionally, its portrayal of Mumbai’s slums was criticized for being exploitative rather than nuanced, leading to debates about its worthiness of the coveted Oscar.
The Shape of Water [2017]:
This was the film that put a HUGE question mark on the decision making of the Academy Awards jury. There was a time when cinema buffs looked up to the Academy Awards as the epitome of excellence. However, after rejecting films like “The Darkest Hour”, “Dunkirk” for an absurd movie with a laughable plot doesn’t seem likely.
While the Oscars aim to celebrate the best in the film industry, these 11 Best Picture winners have, over the years, sparked debates about their worthiness for the prestigious award. The subjective nature of art will inevitably lead to differing opinions, but these movies, in the eyes of many, remain questionable choices for the crowning honor in filmmaking.
Support TFI:
Support us to strengthen the ‘Right’ ideology of cultural nationalism by purchasing the best quality garments from TFI-STORE.COM
