TFIPOST हिन्दी
TFIPOST Global
Tfipost.com
Tfipost.com
No Result
View All Result
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
    Karnataka Govt Blames RCB for Chinnaswamy Stampede

    Congress- led Karnataka Govt Blames RCB for Chinnaswamy Stampede, Cites Kohli’s Video in HC

    Nitish Kumar’s Power Push: Free Electricity Lights Up NDA’s Bihar Campaign

    Nitish Kumar’s Power Push: Free Electricity Lights Up NDA’s Bihar Campaign

    Indian Nurse, Nimisha Priya Faces Execution Today

    Indian Nurse Nimisha Priya Faces Execution Today as Intervention Fails

    Game-Changer: India’s Stealth Bomber to Outfly U.S. B-21, Carry BrahMos Missiles

    ULRA Strategic Bomber: India to Build 12,000-km Beast That Can Outfly U.S. B-21, Carry BrahMos Missiles

    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • All
    • Business
    • Economy1
    • Finance
    AI Appreciation Day Celebrated Globally, Spotlight on Innovation and Ethical Progress

    AI Appreciation Day Celebrated Globally, Spotlight on Innovation and Ethical Progress

    India Achieves 50% Non-Fossil Fuel Power Capacity

    India Achieves 50 pc Non-Fossil Fuel Power Capacity, Five Years Ahead of Schedule

    Advantages of Using an EMI Calculator Before Applying for a Personal Loan

    Advantages of Using an EMI Calculator Before Applying for a Personal Loan

    WiseProfitWay.com reviews – Trading Times

    WiseProfitWay.com reviews – Trading Times

    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • All
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
    CDS Chauhan: India Needs Tomorrow’s Tech to Win Today’s Wars

    India Needs Tomorrow’s Tech to Win Today’s Wars, Says CDS Anil Chauhan; Urges Indigenous Tech Push

    India-U.S. Set to Strike Javelin Deal

    India Seeks Javelin Missile Co-Production Deal with U.S. Under ‘Make in India’ Push

    India Set to Test ET-LDHCM: Hypersonic Missile

    India Tests Hypersonic Missile Aimed at Covering All of Pakistan and Key Chinese Military Zones

    India Conducts Successful Trial of Astra Missile

    India Conducts Successful Trial of Astra Missile BVRAAM Featuring Indigenous RF Seeker

    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • All
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
    Khalistani Sympathiser with Anti-India Stance: Jasmeet Bains

    Khalistani Sympathiser with Anti-India Stance, Jasmeet Bains Aims for California Congress Entry

    Hindu Activist Shot Dead in Cold Blood as Bangladesh Opens Fire

    Hindu Activist Shot Dead in Cold Blood as Bangladesh Army Opens Fire on Peaceful NCP Rally in Gopalganj

    US-DEA Uncovers Canada–Pakistan–China Narco-Terror Nexus

    US-DEA Uncovers Canada–Pakistan–China Narco-Terror Nexus: A Global Hybrid Threat Emerges

    Pakistan Taliban’s Network in Bangladesh Busted

    Pakistan Taliban’s Terror Web Reaches Bangladesh: Two Arrested Over TTP Links

    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • All
    • Culture
    • Education
    • History
    • Indology
    NCERT Textbook Reveals Mughal Religious Intolerance

    Ruthless Babur, Violent Akbar, Destructive Aurangzeb: NCERT Textbook Reveals Mughal Religious Intolerance

    India Built Gardens Long Before Babur Dreamt of Charbagh

    Before the Mughals: India’s Civilisation Built Gardens Long Before Babur Dreamt of Charbaghs

    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    Echoes of the Cholas in Today’s Bharat

    Conqueror of the Seas: Rajendra Chola and the Rise of Naval Bharat

    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • All
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Entertainment
    • Food
    • Games
    • Health
    • Lifestyle
    • Satire
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    Karnataka Govt Blames RCB for Chinnaswamy Stampede

    Congress- led Karnataka Govt Blames RCB for Chinnaswamy Stampede, Cites Kohli’s Video in HC

    Ace Alliance: Accelerating Growth in the European iGaming Market

    Ace Alliance: Accelerating Growth in the European iGaming Market

    Addiction Recovery in India: Breaking Stigmas and Building Support Systems

    Addiction Recovery in India: Breaking Stigmas and Building Support Systems

    How Under Armour’s Women’s Sports Shoes Are Reinventing Women’s Fitness Experience

    How Under Armour’s Women’s Sports Shoes Are Reinventing Women’s Fitness Experience

    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
Tfipost.com
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
    Karnataka Govt Blames RCB for Chinnaswamy Stampede

    Congress- led Karnataka Govt Blames RCB for Chinnaswamy Stampede, Cites Kohli’s Video in HC

    Nitish Kumar’s Power Push: Free Electricity Lights Up NDA’s Bihar Campaign

    Nitish Kumar’s Power Push: Free Electricity Lights Up NDA’s Bihar Campaign

    Indian Nurse, Nimisha Priya Faces Execution Today

    Indian Nurse Nimisha Priya Faces Execution Today as Intervention Fails

    Game-Changer: India’s Stealth Bomber to Outfly U.S. B-21, Carry BrahMos Missiles

    ULRA Strategic Bomber: India to Build 12,000-km Beast That Can Outfly U.S. B-21, Carry BrahMos Missiles

    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • All
    • Business
    • Economy1
    • Finance
    AI Appreciation Day Celebrated Globally, Spotlight on Innovation and Ethical Progress

    AI Appreciation Day Celebrated Globally, Spotlight on Innovation and Ethical Progress

    India Achieves 50% Non-Fossil Fuel Power Capacity

    India Achieves 50 pc Non-Fossil Fuel Power Capacity, Five Years Ahead of Schedule

    Advantages of Using an EMI Calculator Before Applying for a Personal Loan

    Advantages of Using an EMI Calculator Before Applying for a Personal Loan

    WiseProfitWay.com reviews – Trading Times

    WiseProfitWay.com reviews – Trading Times

    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • All
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
    CDS Chauhan: India Needs Tomorrow’s Tech to Win Today’s Wars

    India Needs Tomorrow’s Tech to Win Today’s Wars, Says CDS Anil Chauhan; Urges Indigenous Tech Push

    India-U.S. Set to Strike Javelin Deal

    India Seeks Javelin Missile Co-Production Deal with U.S. Under ‘Make in India’ Push

    India Set to Test ET-LDHCM: Hypersonic Missile

    India Tests Hypersonic Missile Aimed at Covering All of Pakistan and Key Chinese Military Zones

    India Conducts Successful Trial of Astra Missile

    India Conducts Successful Trial of Astra Missile BVRAAM Featuring Indigenous RF Seeker

    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • All
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
    Khalistani Sympathiser with Anti-India Stance: Jasmeet Bains

    Khalistani Sympathiser with Anti-India Stance, Jasmeet Bains Aims for California Congress Entry

    Hindu Activist Shot Dead in Cold Blood as Bangladesh Opens Fire

    Hindu Activist Shot Dead in Cold Blood as Bangladesh Army Opens Fire on Peaceful NCP Rally in Gopalganj

    US-DEA Uncovers Canada–Pakistan–China Narco-Terror Nexus

    US-DEA Uncovers Canada–Pakistan–China Narco-Terror Nexus: A Global Hybrid Threat Emerges

    Pakistan Taliban’s Network in Bangladesh Busted

    Pakistan Taliban’s Terror Web Reaches Bangladesh: Two Arrested Over TTP Links

    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • All
    • Culture
    • Education
    • History
    • Indology
    NCERT Textbook Reveals Mughal Religious Intolerance

    Ruthless Babur, Violent Akbar, Destructive Aurangzeb: NCERT Textbook Reveals Mughal Religious Intolerance

    India Built Gardens Long Before Babur Dreamt of Charbagh

    Before the Mughals: India’s Civilisation Built Gardens Long Before Babur Dreamt of Charbaghs

    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    Revisiting the MANUSMRITI: Why India’s Youth Must Study This Ancient Epic

    Echoes of the Cholas in Today’s Bharat

    Conqueror of the Seas: Rajendra Chola and the Rise of Naval Bharat

    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • All
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Entertainment
    • Food
    • Games
    • Health
    • Lifestyle
    • Satire
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    Karnataka Govt Blames RCB for Chinnaswamy Stampede

    Congress- led Karnataka Govt Blames RCB for Chinnaswamy Stampede, Cites Kohli’s Video in HC

    Ace Alliance: Accelerating Growth in the European iGaming Market

    Ace Alliance: Accelerating Growth in the European iGaming Market

    Addiction Recovery in India: Breaking Stigmas and Building Support Systems

    Addiction Recovery in India: Breaking Stigmas and Building Support Systems

    How Under Armour’s Women’s Sports Shoes Are Reinventing Women’s Fitness Experience

    How Under Armour’s Women’s Sports Shoes Are Reinventing Women’s Fitness Experience

    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
No Result
View All Result
Tfipost.com
Tfipost.com
No Result
View All Result
  • Premium
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Defense
  • Geopolitics
  • Knowledge
  • Law
  • Lounge

Wealth taxes make no economic sense whatsoever

 Arguments in favour of wealth taxes and problems with them

Abhishek Kumar Singh by Abhishek Kumar Singh
10 March 2023
in Analysis
Wealth taxes make no economic sense whatsoever
Share on FacebookShare on X

Look at the person sitting next to you. Anyone. They could be a shop owner, milk seller, friend, one of your parents, your fiancee, or your roommate. What are the similarities between you and them? For one, you both are sapiens and have similar features. Similar, not congruent. And that is where the debate about equal outcomes should die down. But proponents keep claiming that everyone deserves an equal share of society’s wealth. To ensure the fructification of their fantasy land, they are ready to go to any absurd extent possible. And that is how wealth tax made its entry into the economic literature. A 15-minute reflection on the concept is enough for anyone to move on to better thoughts. But, as they say, common sense is not so common. 

Demand for wealth tax intensifies

 As soon as COVID struck, the demand for punishing Indians for their competitiveness started to gain traction. Increased earnings by a few percent of individuals were being shown as a sign of something inherently and structurally wrong with the system. Articles on bringing back wealth tax regimes are being published. Even half-crooked surveys are there, claiming that as many as 80 percent of Indians want rich people to pay more tax. First of all, the survey includes the opinions of 3,231 people. That is an extremely small sample size, but our great media finds it worthy to publish and drive the narrative.

RelatedPosts

Crypto Trading Signals Explained: A Comprehensive Guide

India Sets Record with 174 Advance Pricing Agreements Signed in FY 2024-25

Game Changer for taxpayers: New Income Tax Bill 2025 tabled in Parliament

Load More

Coming back to the point, there are a few key arguments in favour of a wealth tax. Let’s look at them to find out why and how they are wrong. Firstly, a concise and precise definition of wealth tax would be helpful. 

The term

 Wealth tax is simply a tax on the assets that one currently owns. If an authority wants to collect wealth tax from someone, it has to take into account everything named after him or her. These include overall income, gems and jewellery, a house, shares, bonds, debentures, and other assets. After finding the total value of them on a particular date, the government asks the wealthy to pay for it. It’s different from income tax in the sense that you pay income tax only once, while wealth tax applies to any new assets you add to your financial arsenal.

 Arguments in favour of wealth taxes and problems with them

 Proponents of wealth tax have their reasons to love it. They claim that if not taxed properly, it could lead to the incessant accumulation of wealth. This argument is problematic on two levels.

 Firstly, it assumes that the accumulated wealth is not the result of hard work. We have a simplistic belief that wealth is either the product of tyrannical control or is inherited. A part of that may have been true around three decades ago. But the assumption has eroded rapidly, especially with India’s push towards business in the last decade. We have billionaire startup founders who belong to middle-, low-, or lower-class families.

 

The second inherent assumption is that what these people accumulate, they only spend on themselves. You know, foreign tours, expensive parties, sitting on the beach with margaritas. The critics just fail to acknowledge that wealth has a tendency to trickle down the economic ladder.

 

The other argument in favour of a wealth tax is that of inequality. In other words, a small percentage of the population is able to access a major chunk of resources, while a large section remains bereft of those resources. Studies after studies show that income inequality is a problem. According to the latest World Inequality Database, the top 10 percent of wealthy Indians have 65 percent of the country’s wealth. The corresponding figure for the bottom 10 percent is only 6 percent. During COVID times, the numbers got worse as the rich doubled their income while the per capita income of the average Indian dropped.

                               PC: Statista

 

Tax the rich

 Their solution for this disparity is to just tax the rich. Going deeper into the argument will tell you that it relies on the modern concept of the welfare state. Taxing the rich translates to filling up the government’s coffers with more money. This money can then be used by the government to provide services that are mandatory under the welfare state regime. These include free food grain, a clean water connection, a subsidy on electricity, and other benefits. The economic logic behind it is that the government spending the money accrued by rich people creates a demand cycle, benefiting the national economy in the final analysis.

 

Sounds absolutely logical and commonsensical. Right? Of course, and that is the beauty of every rational—or should I say irrational—argument given by the left. It’s just that the solution only worsens the problem.

 

The effects are debilitating

What transpires in real life is that rich people start to refrain from relying on the government. It is not rocket science. These people are not always engaged in corruption, as the media would tell you. Apart from maintaining contacts, these people work more than 80 hours per week. They are hard workers, conscientious, and industrious. Now, if they are putting in so many hours in their work, they would definitely want a return on investment. That is how the human brain works, and that is exactly how industrial units work.

 

Most of them earn money to create more value. Their money creates more money only because the initial money has been invested in something more productive. This investment helps the population through new production lines, new jobs, and an increase in the area’s source of income.

 

Now, if they get to learn that the more money they earn, the government will be charging more taxes, what will be the impact on them? They feel disincentive to earn more and put money back in the economy. These people start to move to destinations that impose less tax, or in some cases, no tax. This phenomenon is called capital flight. The French wealth tax regime serves as a prime example of this phenomenon.

 

According to Eric Pitchet, the French wealth tax regime helped the government earn $20.8 billion between 1998 and 2006. Now comes the funny part. To earn this money, France missed out on $125 billion worth of investment. For context, in FY 2006, FDI in India was less than $10 billion.

 

France is not the only country that has given its support to the concept. Austria, Denmark, Germany, the Netherlands, Finland, Iceland, Luxemburg, Sweden, Norway, Spain, and Switzerland are other major countries that have flirted with this concept. Most of them had to abolish it altogether. The reason is simple. The expectation was that wealth tax revenues as a percentage of GDP would increase. That did not transpire at all.

              

      PCs: UVI

Reasons for failure

 As you can see in these graphs, in more than 90 percent of cases, it even failed to cross the threshold of 1 percent. That is literally the definition of pathetic.

 There are reasons for these failures. These are mainly logistical and technical reasons. One of them is the government not setting the appropriate rate, as they were aware of capital flight but also wanted to avoid it. Classic case of populism taking over common sense. Then there are estimation and liquidity-related issues.

 Given how dynamic the market is, it is next to impossible to find out the accurate price of a particular item. Even if that issue is overcome, how will the wealthy pay their taxes? The big players keep their money in illiquid assets. Most of them just do not have enough cash to pay the authorities. In Austria, these problems resulted in high economic costs of collection, turning wealth tax into that toy that costs more than the child.

India’s tryst with wealth tax was and will always be a failure

In fact, this is the main reason why, in his 2015 budget speech, the late Shri Arun Jaitley decided to get rid of wealth tax in India. Before putting forward the proposal, he asked the audience. Shri Jaitley replaced it with a surcharge of 2 percent on those whose taxable income exceeded Rs 1 crore.

 

In addition to that, almost everything held by wealthy people is already taxed. These include tax on capital gains, gifts, shares, dentures, other financial instruments, and not to forget real estate. All in all, the maximum marginal rate of income tax on India’s super-rich is 42.74 percent. The room for more taxation is really cramped up, especially after the introduction of surcharges.

 

Even if we leave these rich people’s problems aside, a wealth tax only inhibits more people from contributing towards the nation’s development. Where will MSMEs go? They contribute 30 percent of our economy and more than one-third of total income tax collection. Basic common sense tells us that their owners can’t afford wealth taxes. Any such measure would simply short circuit India’s economic journey till date.

 

Despite clear evidence existing against it, the left keeps pushing for a wealth tax. This kind of tax is driven by envy on the part of the majority of common folks. Politicians and academicians push it only to get popular.

Tags: $5 trillion economyIncomeInidarichtaxWealthwealth tax
ShareTweetSend
Previous Post

Durgiana Mandir Amritsar, Timings, History, Travel Guide and How to reach

Next Post

What the Fatwa

Related Posts

Lalu Yadav Family Feud May Derail RJD as Discontent Grows Within
Analysis

Bihar Polls: Lalu Yadav’s Family Feud May Derail RJD’s Plans as Discontent Grows Within

15 July 2025

The Rashtriya Janata Dal, once a dominant force in Bihar politics, appears to be grappling with growing internal discord,...

India Must Stay Vigilant as Turkey-Pakistan Axis Grows
Analysis

Pakistan and Turkey Deepen Anti-India Axis Through Defence, Radicalization Nexus

14 July 2025

In a move that raises fresh concerns for India’s national security, Pakistan and Turkey (Türkiye) are forging deeper military,...

Hindu Faith Under Siege in Tamil Nadu
Analysis

Hindu Faith Under Siege: Mass Religious Conversions Rock Tamil Nadu

14 July 2025

Mass conversions in Tamil Nadu have reached an alarming new peak under the DMK government, with reported coercion of...

Load More

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms of use and Privacy Policy.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Currently Playing

The Butcher of Pahalgam: Sulaiman — Trained by ISI, Pakistan’s Commando-Turned-Terrorist

The Butcher of Pahalgam: Sulaiman — Trained by ISI, Pakistan’s Commando-Turned-Terrorist

00:04:13

Congress’s Rohith Vemula Bill: Caste Polarization Masquerading as Reform

00:07:33

Bhima Koregaon Won’t Be Repeated; Maharashtra’s Special Act to Wipe Out Urban Naxals.

00:06:06

Conqueror of the Seas: Rajendra Chola and the Rise of Naval Bharat

00:07:47

How UPI went global? Why Namibia Adopted It?

00:07:20
Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube
tfipostTfipost.com
Right Wing | News Analysis | Indian Opinion
  • About us
  • Careers
  • Brand Partnerships
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
MASHABLE IS A GLOBAL, MULTI-PLATFORM MEDIA AND ENTERTAINMENT COMPANY. FOR MORE QUERIES AND NEWS, CONTACT US AT info@mashablepartners.com


©2025 TFI Media Private Limited

No Result
View All Result
  • Premium
  • Politics
    • Analysis
    • Opinions
    • Trending
  • Economy
    • Business
    • Finance
  • Defense
    • Defence
    • Strategy
    • Weaponry
  • Geopolitics
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • Europe
    • South Asia
    • West Asia
  • Knowledge
    • Culture
    • History
    • Indology
  • Law
  • Lounge
    • Books
    • Cinema
    • Food
    • Health
    • Sports
    • technology
    • Travel
    • Satire
TFIPOST हिन्दी
TFIPOST Global

©2025 TFI Media Private Limited