When Yograj Singh was given a free run to spew venom against Hindus and use outrageous language against women at one of the farmers’ protest sites during the early days of their Delhi siege, many realised that the driving force behind the agitations was not farm-related issues, but a deep-seated hatred of a sizable chunk of Khalistan-proponents against India, and Hindus. Pussyfooting around the issue will serve no purpose. It is of immediate need that whatever-little support the ridiculous idea of Khalistan has within Indian Sikhs is addressed. In the entirety of the piece, I will be speaking mainly about Indian Sikhs alone. What the diaspora of some anti-India Sikhs (those in foreign nations) do is none of my business. They are neither Indians nor do I consider them Sikhs.
Why? Because of the simple fact that those in foreign countries know nothing about India, and have inflated opinions of the country being no safe place for Sikhs. It is for this very reason that Khalistanis in countries like the US, Canada, UK, and Australia take to attacking Indian nationalists at the drop of a hat. During a recent ‘Tiranga and Maple rally’ in Canada’s Brampton, for instance, Khalistanis attacked members of the Indian diaspora, telling them to “Go and drink cow’s urine.” TFI recently reported about how a man came on a podcast being live-hosted by BBC and slurred Narendra Modi and his mother with abhorrent language. In Australia’s Sydney, prior to the farmers’ agitation even beginning, Harris Park witnessed a bloody brawl after a Khalistani sympathiser took to TikTok to post anti-India videos which were strongly objected by a Haryanvi, resulting in a bloody brawl ending with the main culprit, Jassi getting gravely injured. The minds of such Sikhs are infested with extremism and Hindu-hatred.
So, to hell with some Khalistanis in other countries. Our concern should be Indian Sikhs, who have a lot to get busy with. There are fundamental societal faults existent within the Indian Sikh community. Let no one get up and tell me that I have no right to speak so openly about these faults because I am a part of the community which is currently a victim of the narrative being set by a cocktail of extremists, leftists, political forces and of course, Khalistanis. The levels of misinformation floating around are astronomical and any layman would fall into the vicious trap if not counselled thoroughly otherwise.
Let us talk about some faults within the Sikh community, which if not addressed soon, will not get us anywhere, and will only end up harming us.
Hindu Hatred
The tough one goes up for discussion first. There is no denying the fact that a small part of the Sikh community harbours a seething hatred for the Hindu community. That these are mostly comprised of upper caste individuals is a subject that will be dealt with a bit later in the piece. With the coming of PM Modi in 2014, this hatred for India’s majority community has only turned more poisonous. Finally, a man came to power in Delhi who stood for Hindus, who wore his Sanatan culture on his sleeve proudly and who has himself in the past claimed to be a ‘Hindu Nationalist’. He gave voiceless Hindus a voice.
Khalistanis went berserk merely seeing visuals of Prime Minister Modi. They still cannot stand the very sight of him. The farmers’ protests were an opportunity they just could not miss. Initiated by left-leaning farmers’ unions of Punjab, the agitation soon took the turn of somehow protecting Sikh identity, which, according to the protestors, the BJP-led Modi government is hell-bent on attacking. That no other government in the past has worked a fraction of what the Modi government has when it comes to the welfare of Sikhs and propagation of their glorious history is a separate debate altogether.
Agriculture and ‘Sikhi’ were projected as synonymous. That they are intrinsically connected is something which I do not dispute. But once the religious angle was experimented by Khalistanis in the early days of the agitation, and turned out to work marvellously, the protests became a free ground for separatists to hijack and spew their venom from. All that the protestors needed to be told was that their religious identity, followed by their livelihoods, were being attacked by the Modi government. Soon, Punjab arose seemingly as one entity to agitate against the eternal enemy, that is Delhi.
For Sikhs, Delhi has historically been a symbol of subjugation and oppression. From the times of the Mughals to as recent as Indira Gandhi’s implantation of Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale – Delhi has been at the centre of Sikhs being victimised. But there is a need for the Sikh community to realise this – Delhi of independent India, and especially of 2021, is not your enemy. Hindus are not your enemies. Prime Minister Modi is not your enemy. Unless Sikhs realise this, they will keep falling prey to the devious designs of Khalistanis, political parties and communists.
Jatta Di Shaan
As a thumb rule, I do not consider any individual who identifies himself/herself with their caste, while also proclaiming to be a Sikh, a Sikh. You are either a Jatt or a Sikh. You are either a Mazhabi or a Sikh. There are no grey areas in Sikhi. The mandate on caste is very clear – for Sikhs, there is none. So, when Punjabi songs are weaponised with lyrics of Jatt supremacy and are then used to fuel anger against the Modi government, ‘Dilli’ and Hindus in general – it should be known to all that members of one sub-community of Sikhs (which has come to exist, sadly) are solely behind the ongoing cringe-fest at the borders of the national capital.
The issue is not about farming. The issue is about the pride of Jatts, and how they think the Modi government is walking all over it. How dare the government take decisions on their behalf? A vast majority of those protesting on the borders of Delhi are not ‘farmers. They are agricultural landowners, who have in turn employed labourers to till their fields. These are the people who have a nexus with the arthiyas, and are hence, worked up because, in their sweet and comfortable world, there is no place for a third party (read – private players). So, high on religious toxicity and caste supremacism, our Jatt brothers and sisters have come marching to Delhi with their tractors to agitate against a government that is supposedly hell-bent on usurping their lands.
Also, notice how all those protesting on the borders of Delhi are Jatts and Jaats. The former is from Punjab and Uttarakhand’s Terai region; the latter, from Haryana and western Uttar Pradesh. A classic case of potayto-potahto.
Violence
The farmers lost the plot on January 26, when they stormed the national capital and engaged in violence, apart from desecrating the Red Fort. Those seen engaging in violence too were mostly Sikhs. Before such violence, the protestors were at least being taken seriously. After their show of unnecessary bravado, however, they reduced themselves into a joke. And what, pray tell, did the fringe within my community achieve by hoisting the Nishaan Sahib on the Red Fort? What has changed? Are we suddenly under a Khalsa Raj? If not, why was such a stupid deed done in the first place, which has only created divisions between the protesters (largely Sikhs) and nationalists, when in fact, Sikhs themselves are supposed to be, and a majority still is, among the most nationalistic of communities in India?
I have spoken previously too, about how Sikhs need to cool down and take a chill. These are not the times of the Mughals, and neither do we have to fight the Afghans at midnight. We live in a democracy, in which violence has no place. It would be in the best interest of those who are ever-charged to pounce on just about anybody with their kirpans to start behaving themselves, and not do an entire community a disservice. Those kirpans are holy – meant to be raised only for the purpose of mercy. They are not to be used for cutting the hands and legs of Indian police officers. Those who do want to continue down that path still, should procure Made in China swords and knives for themselves, and give up their kirpans. It is a painful sight to watch when the kirpans are used to attack innocent people, for no fault of theirs.
Not a battle of existence
As a part of the community, I realise that there is this tremendous peer pressure of sorts on fellow Sikhs to stand in support of the farmers protesting on the borders of Delhi. Whether they should support them or not is an educated choice for them to make. However, the need of the hour is to call out, identify and punish the fringe within our community. The new farm reforms are not an existential crisis. None of the Sikhs I have personally interacted with know a damn thing about the farm reforms. All they know is that Modi is a proud Hindu and a bad man looking to attack Sikhs. This is a suicidal approach and will get us nowhere.
The time of fooling around is over. The winters are over. Harvest season is approaching. Let us not be fooled by some vested interest groups and make a mockery out of ourselves. I have known Hindus and Sikhs to be one. We go to Gurdwaras as much as we go to Mandirs. We celebrate Gurpurabs with as much enthusiasm as we observe Navratri. No extremist should be allowed to tell us that we are different. The onus lies on us to call out radical elements and Khalistanis within the community. If we do not, we will have nobody but ourselves to blame for the weakening of the Sikh identity.
Cherry picked, biased article, what about hatred of Hindu’s against the Sikhs? ( Just log into Reddit and have a look ) Do you think thousands of Sikhs committed suicide in 1984? What makes you think foreign Sikhs have no idea about the situation in Punjab? What year are you living in, 1994 with no Internet? First, the Indian government took Punjab’s water away, forcing them to install borewells causing the water table to plummet, then comes the “new farm laws” which are basically nothing but a systematic way of ensuring no stable income and a cyclical poverty trap, you can look at Bihar where the farmers are fairing the worst owning to no MSP ( thanks to the FREE MARKET YAYY! )
At this point, the government just want to suffocate Punjab and get rid of it’s original inhabitants completely and you’re helping them suffocate Punjabis, be proud. What’s next on the menu? Muslims?
1984 murders were done by Congress goons. It was not done by then because they were Hindus. But because they were fanboys of the ‘family’. Whose party is still in power in Punjab.
I grew up in Panjab (a majority of my true friends are Jatt Sikhs), I am living in Brampton, Canada for the last 15 years, again know the community very well here, as this article stated: ” Jattan Di Shaan”, very true > Jatts have great qualities which are unmatched compared to other communities among Indian society, absolutely no doubt, but the biggest skill they lack is the sharpness of political skill , and I tell many times the same to my friends upfront. This is the key reason that every institution where Jatts have majority control has deteriorated over time, whether it is SGPC, Punjab politics, Canadian religious places, Akali Dal and currently the Kisan Andolan or even Hindu hatred among Khalistani block. So I am very confident that this Hatred started by these groups will also fall apart and will not survive much longer. What Hindus need to use the biggest weapon to defeat this fake movement is PATIENCE
1984 author was the grandson of a Mulla who himself was a grandson of Ghiyasudeen. Explain how Punjab river was taken away?…100 percent Sikhs great grand parents were Hindus, most Gurudwaras visitors are Hindus and not Muslims. The holy book GURUGRANTHSAHIB has the name of RAM (not Allah) mentioned many times on its pages. If Khalistani are so brave, I dare you to ask Pakistan to vacate our Lords most important Gurudwara. Punjab is landlocked having border with Pakistan, these Pakistanis sent in 1947 train loads of slaughtered Sikhs from Lahore to Amritsar. Khalistanis will be entirely at the mercy of Pakistan, which will not hesitate to invade, then what? …..Frankly these are not even SIKH, they are bought slaves of lots of money coming from the Islamic and Missionary nations. MONEY BUYS…. Even today Sikhs are hunted in Pakistan, and they take refuge in India. WHY? 1990s Kashmiri Muslims did not spare the Sikh or their Gurudwaras.
You did not really elaborate into ‘why’ some jatt Sikhs hate Hindus.
You talk about the 84 pogrom of the Sikhs. But you don’t talk about the thousands of hindus who were murdered in punjab by sikh terrorists … many more thousands were forced to flee punjab. Once terrorists stopped a bus. They made all the Sikhs alight … then they opened indiscriminate fire on the hindus in the bus and cut them to shreds in their seats … but such is secularism in this county that only minority pogroms are counted ….
Finally saw an article talking some sense on farm law issues and the behaviour of the so-called protesters.
Why do they hate Hindus- there have been no instances of mass Sikh oppression by Hindus ? 84 was done by one family and it wasn’t becoz Sikh offfended Rajiv Gandhi’s Hindu pride
‘pro-Khalistan Sikhs’: A Khalistani cannot be a true Sikh by definition. The Gurus would reject Khalistanis. These rogues are nothing but Pak sponsored extremists. They do the bidding of the Islamic invaders…..the very people our Gurus fought against.
More than 33000 killed in punjab between 1980 to 1990……Guru Granth Sahib says ek omkar universal truth…..I.e. one Om…1984 massacre…..done by son of firoze and indira gandhi….a muslim…..majority of rioteers were Bangladeshi and muslims….himself admitted by Salman khurshid…..wake up to reality….
All hindu neighbors protected their sikh brothers in vicinity, hid them in closets…..protecting them from rioteers…..putting their own lives in danger…..
Contrarily……….similar carnage in Kashmir……..Muslim Kashmiri neighbours………killed their their own hindu neighbours and others happily handed them over to terrorists…..
If you have tunnel vision……you are not a Sikh….nor a follower of Guru granth sahib…..
Sanbeer sir, A day will come when hindus will come for u & your family…then & only then u will remember Khalsa… Reminding u that they even didn’t spared army officers, their families , Khuswant singh spent days in embassy during 1984 genocide because no hindu can be trusted…. your fate will not be different….Raab Rakha….
Hindus and Sikhs are very close. our beliefs are very close, our traditions are very close. indeed, depending on how you define religion, Hinduism, Sikhism, Jainism and Buddhism are like one religion. We have more in similarity than catholics and protestants do with each other but they are classified as one religion, Christian. Hindus and Sikhs have always been best of friends. 1984 was an aberration and terrible tragedy caused by Congress and Gandhi family (ironically, congress is in power in Punjab, one of the few places they have power). usually, Sikhs and Hindus protect each other. indeed, most Sikhs and Hindus don’t look at each other as being different – there is free inter marriage between them, for example, with no family objections. the issue really is political ambition of some people, together with mischief from Pakistan, trying to create a wedge between these two communities, which are almost one. time the common people, the majority of Sikhs and Hindus stand up and join hands and demolish the khalistani elements
As a non-Sikh Punjabi I know of several families who welcome matrimonial alliances with Sikhs ..shows how we open our hearts and home to include them in our lives…never felt apart from them. However the recent show of strength on the borders was nothing but a vulgar display of assertion. To so demean the Tiranga I would hold the Sikhs in and around Delhi totally responsible. To revenge the ’84 riots if this is what we are to be subjected to…I would not hesitate to retaliate…also they need to remember two wrongs cannot make a right