Since 2017, India’s Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime has imposed a 5% tax on crucial disability aids like wheelchairs and Braillers. This tax unfairly penalizes individuals with disabilities, creating an unjust financial burden. For instance, a wheelchair costing ₹1 lakh now incurs an extra ₹5,000 in GST, effectively increasing the cost per kilometer of mobility for those with disabilities.
Legal Concerns Surrounding Disability Aid Taxation
Constitutional Challenges
The GST on disability aids raises questions about its compatibility with Article 14 of the Indian Constitution, which guarantees equality before the law. This tax appears to contradict Section 3 of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, which prohibits discrimination against individuals with disabilities.
Indirect Discrimination and Government Stance
Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud’s 2021 judgment highlighted the need to address indirect discrimination, a concept highly relevant to the GST on disability aids. This tax disproportionately affects people with disabilities compared to the general population. Moreover, it seems inconsistent with the government’s professed concern for disabled individuals, whom Prime Minister Narendra Modi has referred to as “divyang” (divine body).
Precedents in Supreme Court Judgments
Previous Supreme Court rulings have invalidated discriminatory taxes, setting precedents that could apply to the current situation. Notable cases include Sakal Papers (1961), Indian Express (1984), and Aashirwad Films (2007).
Economic and Social Impact on Individuals with Disabilities
The additional tax on essential aids exacerbates the economic strain on individuals with disabilities, who often already face financial challenges. This burden can reinforce social marginalization by making vital tools for mobility and learning more expensive and less accessible. Consequently, people with disabilities may find it harder to participate fully in society, affecting their education, employment, and overall quality of life.
Violation of Equality Principles
Taxing disability aids violates the fundamental principle of equality enshrined in Article 14 of the Indian Constitution. It imposes an undue financial burden on a group already facing significant challenges. This taxation policy indirectly discriminates against people with disabilities, as it disproportionately affects their ability to access essential equipment necessary for their daily lives.
Western Philosophical Views
Western philosophers have long advocated for the fair treatment of individuals with disabilities:
– Immanuel Kant emphasized respecting the dignity and autonomy of all individuals, including those with disabilities.
– John Stuart Mill’s utilitarian principles support policies that maximize overall well-being, including fair treatment and inclusion of disabled individuals.
– Martha Nussbaum’s Capabilities Approach focuses on providing all individuals, including those with disabilities, the means to lead fulfilling lives.
Indian Ethical Perspectives
Indian thinkers have also championed the rights and inclusion of people with disabilities:
– Mahatma Gandhi advocated for the upliftment and inclusion of disabled individuals, stressing compassion and equal opportunities.
– Dr. B.R. Ambedkar supported social justice and equality, emphasizing the need for legal and social reforms to ensure the rights and dignity of all, including those with disabilities.
– Swami Vivekananda highlighted the importance of treating all individuals with respect and ensuring their well-being, regardless of disability status.
Addressing the Disability Tax Issue
To rectify the unfair taxation of disability aids, policymakers should consider the following actions:
1. Reform tax policies to avoid disproportionate impacts on marginalized groups, especially individuals with disabilities.
2. Enhance legal protections to prevent indirect discrimination and ensure inclusivity and fairness.
3. Re-evaluate the GST on essential disability aids, considering their vital role in enabling independence and participation in society.
4. Implement targeted exemptions or rebates for disability-related equipment to alleviate the financial burden on those who rely on these aids.
Promoting Disability Inclusion Through Policy Changes
By addressing the taxation issue on disability aids, the government can take a significant step towards removing barriers to accessibility. This action would align with the principles of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, which aims to create an inclusive society where individuals with disabilities can participate fully and independently.
Enhancing Economic Empowerment
Reducing the financial burden on people with disabilities through tax reforms can contribute to their economic empowerment. With more affordable access to essential aids, individuals with disabilities may find it easier to pursue education and employment opportunities, thereby increasing their economic independence and contribution to society.
Fostering a More Inclusive Society
Reforming policies that unfairly impact people with disabilities sends a powerful message about the value society places on inclusivity and equality. It encourages a shift in societal attitudes towards disability, promoting greater understanding and acceptance of diversity.
In conclusion, addressing the unfair taxation of disability aids is not just a matter of economic policy, but a crucial step towards creating a more equitable and inclusive society. By aligning tax policies with constitutional principles and ethical considerations, India can better support its citizens with disabilities and move towards a future where everyone, regardless of their abilities, has the opportunity to thrive and contribute to the nation’s progress.
ALSO READ: NDA-JDU Relations Ahead: Centre Rejected Bihar’s bid for Special Category Status