This is in response to an article published in the Wire.in titled “What Mahatma Gandhi Said to Those Who Wanted Beef Banned in India”
This article, an excerpt from Gandhi’s prayer discourse of July 25, 1947 summarizes the Mahatma’s response to Rajendra Babu (Dr. Rajendra Prasad) who had presented to Gandhi close to one lakh petitions received in the form of postcards, telegrams, and letters from the Hindus of India demanding a ban on cow-slaughter. In his response, Gandhi while agreeing that the cow was indeed sacred to the Hindus observed however that he could not and would not force anyone to not slaughter cows unless he is himself so disposed. He went on to add “How can I force anyone not to slaughter cows unless he is himself so disposed? It is not as if there were only Hindus in the Indian Union. There are Muslims, Parsis, Christians and other religious groups here.”
While, it is indeed true that these were Gandhi’s views on the specific issue of cow slaughter, it is important however to note that he repeatedly asserted through the course of his life the need to protect the cow while exhorting the Hindus of India to not only involve themselves in cow-protection and “Go-Seva” but also called it their most important sacred duty.
Gandhi being a democrat and a staunch believer in the freedom of choice may have chosen to refrain from airing his own personal views on the specific issue of cow slaughter and/or its ban. However, it must be acknowledged that he was a strong believer and supporter of Gau-protection. His method was perhaps different – he could not and would not force his views on anyone but that does not mean that he supported cow slaughter. Gandhi believed with all his heart that he could convince the Muslims of the country to give up cow slaughter and he held the view that a Muslim killing a cow was akin to him taking the life of his fellow countryman – the Hindu.
A more rounded and complete assessment of Gandhi’s views on cow slaughter and protection is therefore in the interest of fair balance and the principle of presenting both sides of an argument in order that readers are able to make an informed decision. Below are a few excerpts that shine a light on Gandhi’s views on the cow, cow protection, and slaughter.
It might also be pertinent to ponder on what would have been Gandhi’s reaction to the public slaughter of a calf as a means of protest. He would have been appalled to say the least as it went against the most important principle he held dear – Ahimsa.
Below are a few glimpses gleaned from Gandhi’s own writings and speeches that point to Gandhi’s views on the cow-slaughter and present a more rounded and complete picture of what he actually wanted and believed in.
Gandhiji maintained that “Muslims were under no religious obligation to slaughter a cow” Writing on this very subject he went on to observe that “The Koran so far as I have been able to understand it, declares it to be a sin to take the life of any living being without cause. I want to develop the capacity to convince the Musalmans that to kill the cow is practically to kill their fellow countrymen and friends, the Hindus. The Koran says that there can be no heaven for one who sheds the blood of an innocent neighbor1.”
Writing in Young India, Gandhi had this to say about the need for and importance of “cow protection”
“The central fact of Hinduism is cow protection. Cow protection to me is one of the most wonderful phenomena in human evolution. It takes the human being beyond this species. The cow to me means the entire sub-human world. Man through the cow is enjoined to realize his identity with all that lives. Why the cow was selected for apotheosis is obvious to me. The cow was in India the best companion. She was the giver of plenty. Not only did she give milk, but she also made agriculture possible……..
Cow protection is the gift of Hinduism to the world. And Hinduism will live so long as there are Hindus to protect the cow…… Hindus will be judged not by their TILAKS, not by the correct chanting of MANTRAS, not by their pilgrimages, not by their most punctilious observances of caste rules, but their ability to protect the cow2.” [YI; 6-10-1921; p. 36]
Again writing in Young India 1927, Gandhi outlined six points he believed would make the question of cow slaughter “…economically impossible, whereas unfortunately of all places in the world it is the sacred animal of the Hindus which has become cheapest for slaughter.” [YI; 7-7-1927; p. 9 & 10]
- The State should in the open market buy out every cattle offered for sale by out-bidding every other buyer.
- The State should run dairies in all principal towns ensuring a cheap supply of milk.
- The State should run tanneries where the hides, bones, etc., of all dead cattle in its possession should be utilized, and should offer to buy again in the open market all private-owned dead cattle.
- The State should keep model cattle- farms and instruct the people in the art of breeding and keeping cattle.
- The State should make liberal provision for pasture land and import the best experts in the world for imparting a knowledge of the science of cattle to the people.
- There should be a separate department created for the purpose, and no profit should be made in the department, so that the people may receive the full benefit of every improvement that might be made in the different breeds of cattle and other matters pertaining to them
“The foregoing scheme presupposes the State upkeep of all old, maimed and diseased cattle. This no doubt constitutes a heavy burden, but it is a burden which all States, but above all a Hindu State, should gladly bear.”3
During the annual session of the Congress held at Madras in December 1927 Gandhi had agreed to a draft proposal aimed at bringing about Hindu-Muslim unity with just a cursory glance. It contained a line that gave “…Mussulmans a general permission to slaughter cows and the question of cow-protection was conveniently ignored!” Gandhi woke up in the middle of the night in a state of great panic saying
“I have committed a grave error. I did not read the draft properly. But in the night I suddenly remembered that, that draft gave the Mussulmans a general permission to slaughter cows and the question of cow-protection was conveniently ignored! How can I bear this? If they slaughter cows, we cannot stop them by force, it is true, but we can at least win their trust by loving service and explain our point of view to them, can’t we? As for me, not even to win Swaraj will I renounce my principle of cow protection! Go and tell these people that I do not accept that settlement! No matter what the consequences, I will not be a party to cow slaughter!” 4
While no one is disputing the fact that Gandhi did indeed maintain that he would not support an official ban on cow-slaughter, it should also be made clear beyond dispute that he personally held the cow to be sacred and wished that its slaughter be avoided.
The purpose of this article is not to push for a ban on cow slaughter or propose a “beef-ban” but to show that one cannot view Gandhi’s views on the cow and its slaughter through a one-dimensional prism. A more rounded approach to what he said and wrote informs us that he did hold the view that the cow must be protected and indeed cow-slaughter must be avoided.
His method may have differed from that of the present dispensation but Gandhi the man and Gandhi the Hindu did believe that the cow must be protected and he did look for a way in which he, through the force of his personality and the goodwill he enjoyed amongst large sections of the Muslims could bring about a halt to the practice of cow slaughter.
References:
- Available at: Link 1 Last Accessed: June 7, 2017
- Available at: Link 2. Last accessed: June 7, 2017
- A Review of “Beef in ancient India” Gita Press; 1971: “Gandhiji’s Sound Advice”
- A Review of “Beef in ancient India” Gita Press; 1971: “No compromise on cow-slaughter with Muslim league by Mahatma Gandhi” Glimpse No: 78 from the stray glimpses of Bapu” (Second edition, August 1960); Kakasaheb Kalelkar, published by Navjivan Publishing House, Ahmedabad 14.)